BUS POLEAXED BY NEW SAFETY KERB

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, December 15, 2009
Profile image for This is Exeter

This is Exeter

A RAISED kerb created to improve safety on a Mid Devon bridge  at a cost of £8,000 has been blamed for three accidents in a matter of hours.

Around 250 litres of diesel was spilled on Bickleigh Bridge after a bus mounted the new so-called “anti- climb” kerb.

The Stagecoach vehicle was so damaged that it had to be towed away by a recovery lorry and its passengers transferred to a second bus.

And in the three hours it took  firefighters to  clear the scene and reopen the busy A396, another bus  and a car transporter both came a cropper on the same raised concrete strip on Wednesday.

Unapologetic highways chiefs at Devon County Council blamed the accidents on driver error rather than the safety measure they had only just  installed at a cost of  £8,150.

The kerb’s design was approved by English Heritage and Mid Devon’s conservation officer.

But critics of the scheme say the spate of accidents strengthens the case for traffic lights on the narrow bridge.

Nearby resident Tony Davies recalled  hearing a loud noise from his garden when the first bus mounted the kerb.

“It was hit three times in the space of an hour and It will be hit again, I guarantee it won’t be long,” he said.

“At one point that morning, you couldn’t have got a fag paper between the vehicles down there. They were at all different angles to each other. What you needed was someone with a whistle to direct the traffic the old fashioned way. It was more like the Arc de Triomphe out there.”

Mr Davies believes buses and lorries should be banned from using the bridge altogether because they are causing damage that is  often repaired using  taxpayers’ money.

Local county councillor  Polly Colthorpe   was “disappointed” that the kerbing had not had a smooth introduction, but   hoped that the new safety measures would better protect the Grade II listed bridge.

Council records show  Bickleigh  Bridge was damaged 17 times between December 1999 and August 2009  — but in the last 12 months alone it has been hit at least eight times.  More than £10,000 was spent on repairs to the historic span over the River Exe in the year up to last  July.

A Devon County Council spokesman was adamant the new kerbing and white lining had not contributed to the accidents.

The spokesman said: “It is our view that the recent accidents are the result of driver error or misjudgement.

“The protective measures have performed well in as much that the bridge masonry parapet could have been severely damaged had the raised kerbs not been in place.

“The protection works had not been fully completed at the time of the recent incidents and so the kerbing, although fully effective, did suffer some damage and movement.

“The kerbs will be fully reinstated with costs being reclaimed from the vehicle owners’ insurers.

“The effectiveness of the protective measures will continue to be monitored and it is hoped that drivers of large vehicles will be able to negotiate the bridge crossing without damaging this historic structure.”

 

4
Tweet this article
Report

4 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Ian Greenaway, Tiverton

    Sunday, December 27 2009, 12:03PM

    “Traffic lights will cause pollution for residents of Bickleigh whilst traffic sits idling waiting for lights to change. Things which would help are width and weight restrictions. Why is a transporter driver using Bickleigh Bridge when there is the link road for access to the other side of the bridge? If a bus driver can't drive across it without crashing into it, why is he driving that route? I assume that costs detailed in the e-mails below have been reclaimed by the council from the insurers of the vehicles who crashed into the bridge.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by David, Tiverton

    Thursday, December 17 2009, 9:09PM

    “The problem isn't really the council here, it is that the local residents don't want lights. Whilst I do think they should be considered first when it comes to their bridge, with the amount of money we are all spending on this something needs to be done.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Matt, Exeter

    Thursday, December 17 2009, 9:45AM

    “Its a refreshing change to see someone using common sense. Unfortunatley the muppets that seem to be employed by the councils nowadays do not seem have the common sense they were born with. Coming up with a scheme like this would entail a trip out which in hese cold months is not very appealling as its nice and warm in the office!!”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by David, Tiverton

    Wednesday, December 16 2009, 2:06PM

    “Just in case anyone missed the other recent thread discussing the bridge, I submitted an FOI request to DCC to find out just how much has been spent rebuilding it after accidents.

    Since 1 January 2005 and up to 8 August 2009 there have been eight bridge strikes. The repair cost has been £9,803. There have been 17 bridge strikes recorded over the period 13 December 1999 to 8 August 2009. The repair cost over 25 accidents has been £15,490.

    So in the last ten years repairs due to bridge strikes (excluding all other routine works) cost us £25,293, or approx £7 a day. Add to this the cost of other measures such as the £8,000 raised curb, and we have already paid for the typical cost of a three traffic light system, for one year. (Obviously design/installation costs will push that up, but you need to spend money to save money.) That's excluding the significants costs to repair damaged vehicles which someone has to pay.

    Stick one light next to the bus stop on the Tivvy side of the bridge, one just before the Cot's carpark, and one on the Exeter side 10 yards back from the start. All three locations already have existing signage so there would be no additional damage to the street scene. Paint some 'keep clear' lines in front of the car parks and everyone is happy.

    Over the coming years labour and repair costs will go up, the cost of investing in some lights now will surely be lower overall, and much safer.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters