Councils charge us £1.30 a second to park to plug budget gap

Trusted article source icon
Sunday, June 29, 2008
Profile image for This is Plymouth

This is Plymouth

Parking charges in the Westcountry now

cost the region's drivers £1.30 a second as councils use the

levies to plug a budget black hole.

The total raked in from meters and fines across Devon and

Cornwall has soared by 50 per cent in the last five years and

now tops £42 million.Critics claimed motorists were being used

as a "cash cow" to help balance the books.

And soaring charges threaten the future of market towns

deserted by shoppers who flock to out-of-town stores where

parking is free.

"color: rgb(0, 0, 0); text-decoration: none;">

"main2">The official Government figures, released to the House

of Commons library, reveal half of the money received by local

authorities is net profit.

In 2006-7, the year for which the latest figures are available,

£42.7 million was collected from meters, pay-and-display

machines, parking permits and fines.

After the costs of paying traffic wardens and security staff,

running car parks and operating barriers were deducted, it left

a net income of £23 million.

Councils insist the money is needed to plough into services

that are underfunded by the Government. Without sharp increases

in car park charges, more authorities would be forced to breach

rules on capping council tax rises.

Torridge and West Devon MP Geoffrey Cox said: "The car parks in

market towns are a necessary cash cow to stave off the kinds of

rises in council tax that we would otherwise see because of

Labour's failure to fund local government properly.

"But it is causing serious damage to town centres. I have been

talking to councils about the short-sightedness of ratcheting

up parking charges. I have great sympathy with the councils but

I believe they have got to stop it."

Hugh Blaydon, a founding member of the Association of British

Drivers, told the WMN parking charges were necessary to ensure

commuters did not clog spaces meant for short-stay

shoppers.

"But it has gone up and up and up and local authorities have

discovered this is a way of bringing in money to help out their

finances. The motorist is seen as an easy target.."

In 2006-7 Plymouth City Council raised the most in the region

from parking charges - more than £9.2 million - which left the

authority with a net income of almost £5 million.

A council spokesman said the income reflected the fact that

Plymouth was the 14th biggest city in the UK, employing 60

civil enforcement officers and providing 21 pay-and-display car

parks and more than 250 meters.

Penwith council received a net income of £2 million from the

£2.7 million in fines and charges it levelled at drivers, while

Kerrier council, one of the smallest in the region, raised just

£490,000, which added only £196,000 to its coffers.

In Exeter, the 4,300 spaces across 25 car parks generated a

gross income of £2.6 million, producing a profit of £1.9

million. A city council spokesman said much of the money came

from the thousands of visitors to the area. "The income is used

to maintain this level of parking service and also contributes

to the council's overall budget, which in turn helps to keep

council tax charges down."

While the city council receives income from on-street parking

machines, Devon County Council retains the money from

fines.

Torbay MP Adrian Sanders said parking charges remained one of

the few areas of finance over which councils retained control .

"As a result they have become overly dependent on it, to the

detriment of town centres," he said. "Really the answer does

not lie in the field of car park pricing but in the reform of

council finances more widely."

A spokesman for the Local Government Association said:

"Councils don't use parking fines as a revenue-raising exercise

and by law they have to use all money received from fines to

improve local transport.

"It is not in councils' interests to clobber drivers with

fines, but it is their job to keep traffic flowing in town and

city centres and keep drivers moving."

Graham Holland, street scene manager for North Cornwall

District Council which generated net income of £1.2 million,

said: "A proportion of the car park income is used to support

infrastructure of car parks and to improve presentation of

parking facilities.

"Income is also used to help support delivery of non-statutory

duties like our Beach Ranger service and beach life guarding,

and other coast and countryside improvements helping to keep

North Cornwall clean and tidy for residents and visitors

alike."

14
Tweet this article
Report

14 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Wendy Hart, Lipson, Plymouth

    Thursday, July 24 2008, 9:55AM

    “I was given a parking ticket for parking in a restricted parking area at the entrance to Wyndham Square, Stonehouse. I refused to pay because the sign was not visible from where I was parked, 7/8 spaces away. It is 6" from the ground embedded in ivy and tilted to oneside. It could not be seen whilst driving along the road because cars were parked in front of it. At the stage of tribunal appeal the council backed out by simply failing to respond or offer any explaination. If they could not
    justify upholding the fairness of the parking ticket in the first place then why continue for 6 months to the tribunal stage with threats of increased charges. This incident has cause me considerable distress and the expense of paying for photographs to provide evidence of what I was saying. It seems wrong that the council is able to behave in such a cavalier manner without having to account for or explain their behaviour. The situation has not been rectified and the sign remains poorly displ”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by DrT, Ham

    Wednesday, July 02 2008, 6:36PM

    “Keith/Dave. The Herald are right NOT to open up this subject to debate as it will only attract inflammatory and racist comments from the bigots of Plymouth. I applaud their stance in this case. It prevents the further propagation of myths and mis-information that the article tried (admirably) to counter.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Nobby, Mutley

    Monday, June 30 2008, 9:32AM

    “The TWs have clearly got targets to meet, so common sense does not apply!”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by dave, honicknowle

    Sunday, June 29 2008, 9:33PM

    “davey , plymouth. also as they pick up as well. outsidethe steak and omlette i picked up a disabled couple who only go out once a fortnight ... and within 30 seconds of me goin to the door and letting them know i was there i walked back and he slapped a ticket on ... i explaine they were disabled ... he didnt give a toss. i have still not paid the fine . 2 years ago .”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by dave, honicknowle

    Sunday, June 29 2008, 9:24PM

    “keith .... there are quit a few of us that are waiting with our comments... perhaps the herald may eventually take the taxi voting thing off and replace it with this subject which is of more relavance to all communitys ?”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by dave, honicknowle

    Sunday, June 29 2008, 9:20PM

    “just a few days ago the council said they needed to raise the residents parking fees up by 40% because the overheads were to much ... now it seems they make 5 million a year profit according to this report . and they wonder why people get angry ?”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by brian, Plymouth

    Sunday, June 29 2008, 8:09PM

    “I`ve got a blue badge, no problems parking !”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by david, Plymouth

    Sunday, June 29 2008, 3:46PM

    “Beware if you are shopping in Plymouth City Centre,Traffic wardens are now booking people as they drop off their passengers.Nearly as bad as when I went to the firework display,had secure parking,came outside,traffic wardens everywhere booking visitors to a free show.Talk about welcome to Plymouth.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Davey, Plymouth

    Sunday, June 29 2008, 3:41PM

    “Beware i n Plymouth City Centre,Cars are being booked as they drop off their Passengers.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by thoughtful, plymouth

    Sunday, June 29 2008, 1:56PM

    “Keith, I was wondering the same thing but then we are NOT allowed to comment about any of the ethnic minorities it would seem LOL”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters