Anti-nuclear protesters plan biggest ever blockade of Plymouth's dockyard

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, July 20, 2010
Profile image for This is Devon

This is Devon

ANTI-NUCLEAR campaigners are planning to stage the biggest blockade ever held in Plymouth to protest against Trident.

Hundreds of protesters are intending to block all six entrances to Devonport Naval Base and the adjoining dockyard on November 1.

The protest, which organisers describe as a non-violent event, will see anti-nuclear activists from across the country descending on Plymouth.

They are campaigning to highlight the cost of replacing Trident, which is Britain's nuclear deterrent.

The Trident missile defence system is carried on four Vanguard-class submarines.

Devonport is the UK's only base with the specialist facilities and skilled workforce to maintain the submarine fleet.

Meanwhile government departments are still thrashing out details of how the controversial system will be funded.

The coalition Government is planning to renew the system, but the Ministry of Defence and the Treasury departments are at loggerheads about which will foot the multi-billion-pound bill.

Plymouth-based defence expert Iain Ballantyne has warned that placing Trident in the MoD's budget would effectively 'mean the end' of the armed forces with little or no money left to maintain the strength of the Royal Navy, Royal Marines, Army or RAF.

New missile system a waste of money

A CITY campaign group believes the Government should scrap the

controversial Trident missile defence system and pump the money into the

economy.

Shirley Law, a Plymouth-based Trident Ploughshares

campaigner, says in today's economic climate, and with a diminishing

threat of nuclear strikes against Britain, there is "no point" in

renewing the £20billion deterrent.

"When you think how bad the

state of the economy is, and then you consider the politicians are

looking to spend £76billion on replacing Trident, it makes no sense,"

Mrs Law said.

"In this climate it is a huge waste of money and we

just don't want it any more. The greatest risks to us today are global

warming and terrorism. Trident will not help either of those issues."

Mrs Law was speaking as Trident Ploughshares announced plans for a

huge protest in Plymouth on November 1.

The protest to highlight

the cost of replacing Britain's nuclear deterrent will see campaigners

blockade all six of the gates at Devonport Naval Base and the adjoining

dockyard.

Up to 400 protesters are expected to attend the

non-violent protest.

Mrs Law added: "For Plymouth, this will be

the biggest blockade we have ever staged.

"We are expecting at

least 300 or 400 people and we will blockade every gate at the site. We

want to make people stop and think about the stupid idea of replacing

Trident.

"We also want people to consider the proposals to scrap

nuclear submarines in Plymouth. There is no point in complaining after

these things have been decided on. We need to be heard now."

The

blockade will start at 6am on November 1.

During the event

campaigners will be distributing leaflets and displaying posters

highlighting the cause.

On its website, Trident Ploughshares

states Plymouth is becoming known as the 'Sellafield of the South West'

because of its involvement with nuclear submarine refits, maintenance

and upgrades.

Sarah Lasenby, a member of Trident Ploughshares,

said: "This could well be the largest blockade ever staged. In many ways

it should be, given the strength of feeling towards Trident right now."

Plymouth's blockade follows a disarmament camp in Aldermaston in

February which attracted about 1,000 people. Last November about 300

people attended a rally in Devonport protesting against proposals to

scrap nuclear submarines at Devonport Dockyard. The event was organised

by the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament.

An MoD spokesman said:

"We respect everyone's right to peaceful and lawful protest. The Royal

Navy has an excellent safety record in the operation of its nuclear

submarines."

Rebuild delays could bring benefits

DELAYING the replacement of Britain's nuclear deterrent system could

lead to lucrative work at Devonport Dockyard, supporters claim.

While

the coalition Government's Treasury and Ministry of Defence departments

do battle over which will fund the £20billion replacement, many believe

Plymouth in particular could benefit.

The Government has

confirmed it will keep and renew the Trident missile defence system,

which is carried on four Vanguard-class submarines.

With

Devonport being the UK's only base with the specialist facilities and

skilled workforce to maintain the submarine fleet, any delay building

the new fleet would mean Plymouth once again having to refit one or more

of the boats.

These refits are worth hundreds of millions of

pounds to the city's economy. While this could be viewed as a positive

scenario, others aren't quite so good.

One of the proposals to

cut future costs is to reduce the number of Trident-carrying submarines

from four to three. This would take away one of Devonport refits.

This

decision, coupled with the looming Strategic Defence and Security

Review which new Defence Secretary Liam Fox has warned could be 'the

absolute mother of horrors of a spending review', could have huge

implications for the city.

Gary Streeter, Tory MP for South West

Devon, said it is important the correct decision is made to fund a

replacement system.

"The decision has been made to keep and renew

Trident," he said.

"The problem is where the money will come

from to renew it.

"There'll be a knock-on effect if the MoD is

forced to cover it. We need to make sure the outcome of the review is

the correct one. I think the Treasury will have to find a way to fund

part of it."

Alison Seabeck, Labour MP for Plymouth Moorview —

who now sits on the influential Defence Select Committee — said the

issue is "impossible to call" and believed an announcement on Trident

will be made later this month.

Roger Darcy, chairman of Devonport

Dockyard's industrial trade unions, said concerns among workers had not

diminished.

"We've heard rumours, including the one about

extending Vanguard's life," he said.

"That would be a good thing,

but then we hear the MoD's being told to cut 20 per cent from its

budget.

"We rely on workloads from the MoD, so there's still that

concern."

Plymouth-based defence expert Iain Ballantyne said the

future of Trident would depend on how ruthless the Government wanted to

be.

"If Trident is placed within the MoD's budget they might as

well turn off the lights on the UK's armed forces," he said.

"Trident

would blow the budget apart and mean the end of the armed forces."

He

added: "Delaying the replacement would help to retain skills in

Devonport and give us another multi-million-pound refit."

But

Sarah Lasenby, of Trident Ploughshares, said the campaign group would

like to see Trident scrapped altogether.

"It's a devilishly

expensive thing and the money would be far more use elsewhere in

society," said Mrs Lasenby.

Details of the Strategic Defence and

Security Review are expected this autumn.

26
Tweet this article
Report

26 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Julian, Slovenia

    Wednesday, August 04 2010, 8:35PM

    “I'm a professional protestor. Buy this domain and I'll protest some more. Don't buy it...and I'll protest some more. http://www.jets.si/bomb.htm”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Stephen, Ashburton

    Tuesday, August 03 2010, 10:36PM

    “I'm a little sad to read people still trotting out this 'great unwashed unemployed professional protester' nonsense - Where do you get it from?

    I'll be there, I'll take a day off work and it'll cost me a days wages - like many other people who will be there.
    I'm simply not prepared to do nothing whilst the taxes I pay are handed over to foreign companies like Babcock to do a poor job of maintaining a system which not only is useless and dangerous, but which encourages and supports other countries to justify developing nuclear weapons.
    It is easy and, I would suggest, a little childish to sneer at the potential small size of the protest.
    It would be more useful, I would suggest, to demand that some of that huge pile of our cash they're aiming to spend on Trident is put into local industry which has a long term future, like developing wave power, wind power, more efficient shipping systems etc. etc. etc.

    To just stick your head in the sand and hope that the dockyard in its present form is going to continue to provide local jobs, whilst in reality the work gets more dangerous, and more limited, and the foreign companies cream off more of our money, is not going to get you what I hope you want - a decent future for the city.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by R O Tate, Plymuff

    Wednesday, July 21 2010, 9:31AM

    “Perhaps when the great unwashed descend on the city the council will have a cleaning station to wash the scum off them and cleanse them of the dirt and lies they spread in the name of saving the planet and help us poor people of Plymouth. The DWP may also have a mobile office set up so they can sign on whilst lying in the road stopping people getting to work.

    Get real and go and do your scaremongering somewhere else.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by happy hippie, plymouth

    Wednesday, July 21 2010, 8:31AM

    “you guys are all pathetic - the dockyard only provides a quarter of the jobs as it used to - if that! The government want to spend 76bn on renewing trident - when to be frank - places - especially towns like plymouth - could use some of that money in more constructive ways - just head to union st to know what im talking about - they've stopped the schools programme - which would be benifitting lots of local schools and it is about time - people stood up to this and said no!!!! Considering plymouth has some of the worst school in the country - i would have thought some of you might agree. Plus the fact that the government are ploanning on turning the 'dockyard' which seems to be the 'pride' of plymouth - into a nuclear graveyard - cutting up decomiisioned subs there and leaving them to rot - right next to local schools - never been done before! FOR A BLOODY GOOD REASON! I will be there to support the blockade - and I expect i have better prospects than alot of the morons posting on here - decent job thanyou very much! I think its about time ablot of you stopped wasting comment boxes slagging the rest of the world off woke up and looked in the mirror! Plymouth could be a great city - get rid of the dockyard and bring back the many workers who have lost their jobs and let them put thier skills to good use - VESTAS FACTORY anyone? :)”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Tim, Plymouth

    Tuesday, July 20 2010, 9:27PM

    “Based on the last amount of protestors that turned up - I calculate that as around 5 protestors on each gate. What a joke and what a waste of money for a bunch of losers!!”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by manadon39, PLYMOUTH

    Tuesday, July 20 2010, 9:06PM

    “oh another massive demo by Trident ploughshares, what was the count last time,20?? and most of them were travelling hippes from hundreds of miles away...leave the workers of Plymouth to get on with the jobs they are so skilled at at stop poking your crusty noses into our lives.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by plymouthian, plymouth

    Tuesday, July 20 2010, 9:03PM

    “Here we go again, Trident ploughshares spouting off stating they will have have hundreds of supporters, evryone knows that in reality approx 30 people turn up and nearly all of them are travelling hippes from up north, shame on the herald for giving these bigots front page news, kind regards a.dockyardie.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Steve, Plymouth

    Tuesday, July 20 2010, 8:46PM

    “This will be a small protest that should be ignored by the media. They do not represent the majority view otherwise their would be hundreds of thousands outside the gates. Quite simply, they are professional protesters who have no intention of doing a proper days work like the rest of us. Keep your leftie views to yourself. The economy wouldn't have been so bad if it wasn't for commie Gordon trying to cling onto power by throwing money at every votecatching scheme.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Andy, Plymouth

    Tuesday, July 20 2010, 6:40PM

    “The only thing that keeps us from being a complete international laughing stock and our place on the security council.

    Bring it!”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Richard, Plymouth

    Tuesday, July 20 2010, 3:23PM

    “These weapons of mass destruction are expensive and unnecessary. We as a country need to save money, scrapping the Trident weapons of mass destruction program will save us £76billion.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters