Fury over costly Devon carve-up

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, February 11, 2010
Profile image for This is Plymouth

This is Plymouth

​THE Government has been accused of “carving up Devon for its  own political gain” after it decided  to let Exeter run all its own affairs  as a stand-alone council like Plymouth.

Council taxpayers in Devon could pick  up a big bill for the decision, a leading  politician has warned.

After two years of rows and uncertainty,  the Government decided yesterday that  Exeter City Council could become a unitary  authority like Plymouth, running everything from schools to transport alongside  existing services like waste.

Plymouth council leader Vivien Pengelly  called it a baffling waste of public money.

In 2007 the former Secretary of State  Hazel Blears judged that a unitary Exeter  was financially unviable.

 The Government ordered the Boundary  Committee to examine other scenarios for  unitary authorities in Devon.

After a lengthy and costly public inquiry  the committee recommended that all district councils could be abolished leaving  Devon County Council to run local government outside Plymouth and Torbay.

Instead the Government has decided to  revive the Exeter option, leaving local government in the rest of Devon unchanged.

Mrs Pengelly said: “This whole process  has been a shambles from the start and I  shudder to think about the amount of  public money wasted. This is another  baffling episode in a long and sorry  saga.”

Cllr James McInnes, the leader of West  Devon Borough Council, said: “The Government is carving up Devon for its own  political gain which will fracture the county irrevocably. This is a tragedy for Devon.

“If the figures didn’t stack up for Exeter  in 2007, they surely won’t stack up now,  particularly as we are just emerging from  one of the longest recessions in history.

“This entire process has wasted millions of pounds in public money and precious time for all the local authorities  involved.”

Cllr John Tucker, the leader of South  Hams District Council, said:  “We did not  seek this review which has wasted a vast  amount of public money and caused much  additional work for the authorities involved.

 “The clear message we received from our residents was  that they wanted to keep the  status quo – keeping services  local, relevant to local people and  maintaining local accountability.

“It remains to be seen if the  financial case for a Unitary Exeter will really stack up without  causing financial hardship to the  rest of the county.”

The proposal for a unitary authority in Exeter will now be  voted on by Parliament before it  becomes law. If Parliament  agrees, the city can start putting  in place transitional arrangements ready  for elections to a new council in 2011.

Gary Streeter, Tory MP for South West  Devon, says the green light by ministers for  Exeter to go it alone will place huge pressures on the rest of the county.

Mr Streeter said: “The reality is ripping  Exeter out of Devon county is like ripping  the heart out of a body.

“It will place huge challenges upon the  rest of Devon in terms of how it functions  and it will cost taxpayers in Exeter and  Devon an awful lot more in council tax.

“It’s a very nakedly political decision, an  attempt to save one single Labour seat and  I think it’s deplorable. We will do our  utmost to block it.”

Leader of Devon County Council John  Hart added: “This decision is complete  madness and we will fight it all the way.”

6
Tweet this article
Report

6 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by carl, Plymouth

    Sunday, February 14 2010, 10:07PM

    “When the Leader of Exeter City Council says that no new jobs will be required as the staff will transfer from the County Council, does the idiot honestly beleive that there are staff in County Hall pigeon holed to each district/city council .. in this case ready to be shipped to Exeter Council. Does he honestly believe that all the school systems, library systems, social services systems are ring fenced at this moment, ready to have their chunks trimmed off and moved to the city council - no - a complete cloud cuckoo land here, it will all mean duplication of tasks/systems, with very little ability for the county to make savings by any slithers that do move - so no savings for County and massive costs for Exeter - a city Council already in dire financial stress.

    Plymouth (a much larger city!) had a traumatic time becoming a unitary, with continuiing dire finances ... and Torbay ... need we go there ! Gerrymandering is what is is - a plain political decision - embarrassing to us all, and sure to be shown so in the courts very soon.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by johnno, pennycomequick

    Thursday, February 11 2010, 3:06PM

    “I think pengelly has a cheek , to comment on wasting money , she Paid £1 million of our money to find the value of City Bus then sold it for a song , what cheek”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Rick O'Shay, zog

    Thursday, February 11 2010, 2:36PM

    “This is yet another mad decision by Gordon Broon designed to try and save his skin and those of Labour MP's.

    Add to this his plans for changing the electoral system, and the stuff about the long term care of the elderly and it's clear that he is losing the plot radically.

    He clearly is not concerned about any long term strategy or what is best for society as a whole, he just wants to manipulate issues and bribe certain groups of voters in a desperate attempt to retain power.

    I wonder which will happen first: a general election or Broon becoming the first PM in history to be dragged off to the lunatic asylum.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by T A Griffin, Exeter, Devon, England

    Thursday, February 11 2010, 11:52AM

    “Please help us. This decision is unbelievable. Exeter can't afford the cost of its schools, it can't afford social services, it can't afford the hospital, it can't afford to get rid of all its waste, it can't afford care for the elderly, it can't afford anything. When they say it 'ruled' itself for 200 years before the early seventies please ask how many people in Exeter had the vote in running the country for those two hundred years. This is a terrible decision, Exeter, the so called capital of Devon.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Brian, Plymouth

    Thursday, February 11 2010, 10:40AM

    “Well, Mrs P should know all about wasting public money - she holds a gold medal.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Dave, Mutley

    Thursday, February 11 2010, 10:22AM

    “We in Plymouth bemoan the high salary to Barryy Keen, and yet the ovt has spent MILLIONS just trying to keep Ben Bradshaw in a job for another few years.

    Madness”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters