Horsemeat scandal Q&A: the facts and what you should do

Trusted article source icon
Monday, February 11, 2013
Profile image for This is Plymouth

This is Plymouth

Consumers should brace themselves for more unwelcome news this week in the ongoing horsemeat scandal, the Government has warned.

While all processed beef products are safe to eat, further revelations are likely as tests are carried out.

  1. Burger

    Food retailers have been told to carry out tests on all processed beef products

Food retailers have been told to carry out tests on all processed beef products after some Findus lasagne were found to contain more than 60 per cent horse meat.

The horsemeat scandal kicked off last month when Irish food inspectors announced they had found horsemeat in some burgers stocked by a number of UK supermarket chains including Tesco, Iceland and Lidl.

BUY NOW - PAY NEXT MONTH (on all floor sanding works)

Plymouth Floor Sanding

View details

Print voucher

This voucher if printed off and given to us on the day of the quotation entitles you to have your floor sanding work completed, you pay a small deposit & then pay next month.

Terms: 1 voucher per person.
1 voucher per household.
Payment to be settled in full 28 days from completion date (+10% charge).
A payment contract will be signed.

Contact: 01752 421711

Valid until: Sunday, June 30 2013

It emerged over the weekend horse meat contamination may have found its way into school meals and hospital food across the country.

Environmental health officers from Nottingham City Council are carrying out checks following the nationwide controversy. The council has not confirmed exactly what food is being checked, but it provides food for some schools, day centres and residential homes.

Meanwhile the suppliers of school and community meals in Bath have assured their produce does not contain horsemeat.

But how did the scandal come to light and what should consumers do? Find out with our Q&A guide:

The basics

The horsemeat controversy came to light last month when the Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI) revealed 10 of the 27 burger products it had tested contained traces of horse DNA and 23 contained pig DNA.

Burgers containing almost 30 per cent horsemeat were found in a brand sold by Tesco, and smaller amounts of horsemeat and pig DNA were established in other products.

The FSAI said the meat came from two processing plants in Ireland - Silvercrest Foods in County Monaghan and Liffey Meats in County Cavan - and the Dalepak Hambleton plant in Yorkshire.

The BBC explains: “Subsequent tests saw Rangeland Foods in Co Monaghan, which supplies one of Ireland's biggest burger chains, shut down after a sample at the factory tested positive with a reading of 75 per cent horse DNA in raw ingredient.

“In the case of Silvercrest and Rangeland, the FSAI believe the horsemeat was introduced in blocks of frozen burger filler product imported from Poland”.

The focus switched to Romania over the weekend, as it emerged officials are investigating whether horsemeat found in beef products in Britain and France came from a Romanian abattoir.

The Independent yesterday reported horse meat found in British supermarkets could be donkey meat. Horses have been banned from Romanian roads and millions of animals – potentially including donkeys - have been sent to the slaughterhouse, campaigners say.

The Romanian prime minister today denied allegations two abattoirs in his country sold horsemeat purported to be beef to European food companies.

What is being done?

The Food Standards Agency (FSA) has started a sampling programme to investigate how far the contaminated products have been distributed, and ordered food businesses to carry out authenticity tests on all beef products such as beef burgers and meatballs.

The tests are for significant levels of horsemeat, and businesses must have the first set of results by Friday February 15.

The FSA is also conducting a survey in which 28 local authorities across the UK will take a total of 224 samples in accordance with a detailed protocol, with the aim of selecting products which are representative of goods on the market.

The FSA will publish the results from the study, including brand names, and will disclose any formal action taken. It is anticipated a full analysis of the results of this survey will be published in April 2013.

The FSA is also considering whether legal action is appropriate.

Meanwhile Findus has been ordered by the FSA to test its beef lasagne which contains horse meat for the veterinary drug phenylbutazone, or 'bute'.

Animals treated with phenylbutazone are not allowed to enter the food chain as it may pose a risk to human health. The outcome of this test is expected over the next few days and will be published on the FSA website.

The following products have been recalled:

- Aldi Today’s Special Frozen Beef Lasagne and Aldi Today’s Special Frozen Spaghetti Bolognese

- Findus Frozen Beef Lasagne (320g; 360g and 500g; all date codes affected)

- Tesco Everyday Value spaghetti bolognese

- Tesco Everyday Value eight-pack of frozen beef burgers; Tesco four-pack of frozen beef quarter pounders and Flamehouse frozen chargrilled quarter pounders

I’ve already eaten the products named – what should I do?

The FSA says there is currently no reason to think there is a food safety problem with the horse meat.

On its website, the FSA says: “Horse meat is not a risk in itself. However, if the horses have illegally got into the food chain, they may contain the veterinary drug phenylbutazone, or 'bute'.

“‘Bute’ is not allowed in the food chain because in humans it can cause rare cases of a serious blood disorder, aplastic anaemia. Because it is not possible to say what triggers the anaemia, it is not possible to identify a safe level of residue in meat.

“Bute was banned from use in humans after it was found that about 1 person in 30,000 recipients suffered a serious side effect. But in levels reported in previous FSA testing of contaminated meat, the maximum level found would have to be multiplied a thousand-fold to be at the same level as that which used to be given to humans.

“This suggests that even if you have eaten products which contain contaminated horse meat, the risk of damage to your health is very low.”

The UK's chief medical officer Dame Sally Davies today said there is a "limited public health risk" if 'bute' is found in beef products which have been adulterated with horsemeat.

Meanwhile Findus lasagne have been withdrawn from sale, and anyone who has this product in their freezer should return it to retailers as a precaution.

What should consumers do now?

As explained above, the evidence to date does not suggest there is a food safety risk. If further information indicates any health risk, the FSA will provide consumers with advice.

There is no reason to suspect there is any health issue with meat products in general, the FSA says, and it would not advise people to stop eating them.

But people who have bought Findus beef lasagne products are advised not to eat them.

In a bid to reassure consumers the FSA has also announced in future the results of tests on meat set to appear on UK shelves will be made public. It has said it will now work with businesses to establish a standardised sampling and testing system.

I don’t really care if I eat horsemeat. What’s the big deal?

Food labelling rules state a product's label must not mislead, so if a product is labelled a burger it would have to state all the types of meat in it.

Earlier this month the FSA said: “This is a very serious issue. The evidence we have about the two cases, of the significant amount of horse meat in burgers and lasagne, points to either gross negligence or deliberate contamination in the food chain.

“This is why we have already involved the police, both here and in Europe”.

8
Tweet this article
Report

8 Comments

  • Profile image for harryblack

    by harryblack

    Tuesday, February 12 2013, 6:47AM

    “"What's for tea Mum? I'm so hungry I could eat a horse!"
    What???”

  • Profile image for jabbathebutt

    by jabbathebutt

    Monday, February 11 2013, 11:12PM

    “This should really bring to the forefront of us all shopping at supermarkets . We all know but hide it away in our minds of all how mass produced food is made . We have seen local outlets closed because of it . And I am as guilty as the rest for "hoping "that safety was a major concern with all the regulations that the EU espouse .
    For me ,this just is not about horse meat . Its about a total and utter failure of the whole system of a very,if not the most important thing . Its what we are feeding not only us but our children . We trusted and have been let down badly .
    I went into a shop today and was looking for something to take home to eat and cook . Everything I looked at made me think of this whole thing . I walked away with nothing . It really made me look at the blurb on the packet . I trust nothing now .”

  • Profile image for HermesThelema

    by HermesThelema

    Monday, February 11 2013, 10:30PM

    “With respects;
    Grand Master

    Your diet hast been proven
    To contain and be of
    Little sustenance
    Poor quality
    And generally of a standard
    That does not benefit human consumption

    Grand Lodge Great Britain”

  • Profile image for jabbathebutt

    by jabbathebutt

    Monday, February 11 2013, 8:49PM

    “@charlie,mick or whoever you are are in your mind this month . As you dont get the drift of the whole thing which the rest of us do, I will explain it carefully so even you can understand .
    There is nothing wrong with "you" wanting to eat anything "you" like . The difference is being sold one thing described as another , and to be honest ,if they are that unscrupulous in their nature then god help us what health things are not checked and it seems to have been that way for at least 10 years.
    Remember the Barbican fish and chip shop that sold foriegn river fish as cod ? I remember you had plenty to say about that .”

  • Profile image for bluemoonboy

    by bluemoonboy

    Monday, February 11 2013, 8:28PM

    “Don't know what the fuss is all about. At least one Plymouth pasty supplier has been making pasties made from Dartmoor pony for donkeys years!!!! Neigh lad!”

  • Profile image for CharlieDodd

    by CharlieDodd

    Monday, February 11 2013, 7:02PM

    “I've never tried horsemeat but what's wrong with it anyway?
    Thousands of Napoleons troops kept from starving on the retreat from Moscow by eating the cavalry's horses”

  • Profile image for OutsideView

    by OutsideView

    Monday, February 11 2013, 5:46PM

    “The issue is misrepresentation not so much that horsemeat is present.

    misrepresentation of any other product that does not even contain meat at all would fall within the same category.

    The current issue of products containing horsemeat has been surrouded with hysteria and hype leading to the destruction of many products that could have been offered to many people in need provided that the the products were prominently labelled as containing horsemeat or whatever.

    Who knows how long these product have been sold prior to the discovery of the horsemeat content. Was it weeks, months or even years perhaps. There has been no reported epidemic of people falling sick due to any possible contamination. Until it was reported that horsemeat was contained in the products people happily ate them.

    In any event,what evidence is there that the beef does not contain phenylbutazone or any other drug or hormone.”

  • Profile image for newjanner

    by newjanner

    Monday, February 11 2013, 4:34PM

    “If this was a small local butcher it would be closed down but as its Findus, a huge multinational business, nothing would be done. Boycott Findus and any shop that sells its products until they are withdrawn”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article