Incinerator roadshow ends in city centre
PLANS to build an £100million incinerator went on display in Plymouth city centre as a month-long 'waste roadshow' drew to a close.
Around 50 people came through the doors of the Guildhall to find out more about a proposed energy from waste (EfW) plant, which will handle household rubbish from Plymouth, Torbay and South Devon.
-

The South West Devon Waste Partnership (SWDWP) decided it was time to show off the plans drawn up by its four remaining bidders after it announced five other interested firms were out of the running.
German waste company MVV Umwelt has proposed incinerators at sites in Ernesettle and in Devonport Naval Base's North Yard, while Sita has put forward a proposal for the South Yard. Viridor is focusing on its own site at New England Quarry near Lee Mill.
The plans have come up against fierce opposition in Ernesettle and the STIFLE (Stop The Incinerator Fouling Land at Ernesettle) group also set up shop in the Guildhall to raise awareness of their campaign.
STIFLE's Stuart Lane, also a lecturer at the University of Plymouth, described the proposal as "anti-social", adding that increased recycling should be the way forward.
He said: "Overall there is a feeling that perhaps this is both the wrong site and the wrong technology.
"A number of people share our concerns about noise, smells and pollution in general.
"It isn't a brownfield site and what local people want to see there is more access to recreational facilities."
Project director for the SWDWP, Mark Turner, said the roadshow was aimed at allaying fears over views, emissions and traffic, especially from those living near the proposed sites.
He said: "The more people we can talk to the better.
"We're looking at every aspect of this to make sure we don't miss a trick.
"We're genuinely trying to do the best we can and this is helping to get the message across.
"It's great that people have been coming with really good questions - and hopefully they are walking away with a better understanding."
However, Estover couple Andrew and Faye Blackwell, who were at the event to oppose the Naval Base proposals, demanded a full public meeting.
"We have got to look at the long-term aspects of this," Andrew said. "Not only does it affect us, it will affect our children and our childrens' children."
Faye added: "I'm concerned about the health risks and putting it in the Devonport doesn't make sense with so many people living nearby."
Gitty Ankers, environmental waste planner for the Environment Agency, which will regulate the proposed incinerator, said: "We're not here to say 'This is the technology Plymouth should go for'.
"There are other techniques to dealing with waste but we need to get energy from our waste.
"As a society we can no longer put it into landfill."
Read the arguments at www.ernesettle.org.uk and www.plymouth.gov.uk/swdwp.html








11 Comments
View all
by It's obvious, !
Sunday, November 15 2009, 6:08PM
“The site at Lee Mill is the obvious choice. Just do it and save all the mucking about.”
by South Devon Resident, Ivybridge
Sunday, November 15 2009, 5:53PM
“Oh - I see my two comments from earlier today havent arrived here. Why is that Herald?”
by ray rees, plymouth
Sunday, November 15 2009, 5:27PM
“well said ian as the ILL WINDS BLOW ACROSS OUR POPULATED CITY WITH THESE TOXIC & HAZRDUST CHEMICALS THAT WE WILL BE BREATHING & IS NOW THE MAJOR CAUSE OF CANCERS NOW BEING FORMED HERE IN THE WEST COUNTRY AS THE SECOND HIGHEST RATES OF CANCER IN ENGLAND TODAY OTHER THAN SELLAFEILD IN CUMBRIA THE OTHER NUCLEAR PROCESSING PLANT THIS IRONICAL THAT DERRIFORD N H S COULD ANTICIPATE BUILDING A NEW CANCER TREATING BUILDING FOR ITS SHARE HOLDERS TO MAKE PROFIT FROM THE SUFERING OF OTHERS GUESS WHO THEY ARE WHO JUST BEEN RE APPIONTED !”
by fay, plymuoth
Sunday, November 15 2009, 5:07PM
“well said ian”
by ian, Plymouth
Sunday, November 15 2009, 12:06PM
“Obviously they want to build this monsterosity in the Dockyard or close to it so they can burn the low level radioactive waste they generate when they start breaking submarines. Overalls, gloves and numerous other combustable materials that are already on the submarines.
Why do you think Babcock are so keen to see it in the Yard.
The Blight of nuclear dismantling is bad enough without still more rubbish being brought into the city.
This should not be allowed to happen.”
by South Devon Resident, Ivybridge
Sunday, November 15 2009, 9:37AM
“Sorry - that should read
www.ecoivy.org
New website full of well informed info”
by South Devon Resident, Ivybridge
Sunday, November 15 2009, 9:30AM
“Lee Mill doesnt make sense. Roads too small and already over-subscribed with Tesco's in the area to have all this lorry traffic in the lanes as well.
Check out www.ecoivy.com and see what this awful project is all about. Why dont the planners THINK and listen to the residents of the area proposed?????”
by matt, plymouth
Sunday, November 15 2009, 9:22AM
“Surely Lee Mill would make so much more sence.”
by Mick, Barbican
Sunday, November 15 2009, 3:36AM
“How many lorries per day will be going to and from it from the whole of Sth Devon?”
by NIMBY, Plymouth
Saturday, November 14 2009, 9:51PM
“I would have thought with it's easy access from major routes that Ernesettle would have been the perfect site.”