Lack of rail improvements will deepen transport pit
THE South West's rail services to London have been in limbo for longer than I can remember so a few more years of rail franchise delay is hardly going to make any great difference to Plymouth and its under-performing economy.
Unlike elsewhere in the country there are going to be no new trains or infrastructure in this part of the railway world for the foreseeable future. Just a new coat of paint and new staff uniforms probably to reflect the corporate image of the eventual new Great Western franchise and its train operating company.
The best we can hope for are some newer second hand diesel trains released by electrification elsewhere in the country possibly cascaded post electrification Midland main line/Great Western main line Meridian class 222 inter-city trains (similar to the current Crosscountry Voyager trains) and Thames turbo class 165/166 local trains respectively. In the meantime it will be the same old British Rail trains simply refurbished (both high speed and local) running virtually to the same old 1980s schedules while much of the rest of the country get electrification and newer faster trains.
The Prime Minister announcing the Government's latest £9billion rail investment package in Derby said that as a result of its latest £9billion investment package that no less than 75 per cent of rail journeys made in Britain from 2019 will use to quote the Prime Ministers words "faster, cleaner electric trains" and on upgraded rail infrastructure as well.
BRAND NEW FORD B-MAX ZETEC 1.0 ECOBOOST FOR ONLY £7685*
View details
DRIVE AWAY A BRAND NEW FORD B-MAX ZETEC FOR ONLY £7685.
1.0 100PS Manual
WITH:
Electric Windows & Mirrors
Quickclear Heated Windscreen
15" Alloy Wheels
Bluetooth with Ford Sync
Fog Lights
Terms:
*Drive away from only £7685 and then pay nothing for 24 months!
4.9% APR
Conditions Apply
Contact: 01626 240583
Valid until: Sunday, June 30 2013
You have not got to be an economic genius to work out the consequences of all that on Plymouth. Throw in HS2 the proposed North/South high speed rail link as well and you really see the transport pit that Plymouth is sinking into. The far South West is effectively on the way to becoming the nation's heritage railway in the 21st century with little real incentive for business to look further west than Exeter.
A few extra three-hour rail journeys to Paddington even if we can get them and an extra early morning arrival from London Paddington are not really going to fundamentally change the economic imbalance that now so favours Exeter's booming economy.
No major inward investor of consequence in their right mind is now going to bypass Exeter now just two hours plus rail journey time from Paddington, at the end of the M5 and with a decent airport to set up in Plymouth a further one hour rail journey time beyond Exeter, connected with a sub standard A38 dual carriageway and with no airport either. Even Newton Abbot/Torbay with the soon to be built Kingsteignton bypass and only 20 minutes by rail beyond Exeter will be more favourable for economic development than Plymouth connectivity wise.
Like it or not Plymouth has been well and truly stuffed economically thanks to its poor connectively and lack of investment in vital transport infrastructure over many decades by governments and councils alike whether publicly or privately funded.
BRIAN WOODS
Southway




Comments
by hstmtu4000
Friday, October 26 2012, 10:10AM
“CharlieDodd I noticed that myself when I visited Exeter city centre last week.But the loss of just one coffee shop and that's all it is due to I suspect its now relatively peripheral position on the edge of the city centre is merely a drop in Exeter's otherwise buoyant retail and service sectors.The closure of one branch of starbucks http://tinyurl.com/c2s2zym has been more than compensated by the opening of the John Lewis store which also has a cafe funny enough selling coffee.
Basically the Exeter economy is relatively unaffected by the economic crisis and is still growing rapidly unlike Plymouth which seems destined to stagnate economically at best or continue to decline at worst as things stand.
Even when the economy picks up again the slack will be taken up by the better connected cities elsewhere in the country like Exeter as has always happened historically.Only when investors have exhausted opportunities elsewhere do they consider Plymouth by which time of the economic cycle the next downturn is upon us and Plymouth once again misses the investment boat.In desperation we end up having to grab anything or miss out completely. Hence the dreadful outside appearance of Drake Circus shopping centre and the Staples building etc etc.That sadly is the way it is for Plymouth at the moment in the 21st century because of our economic peripherality.
But you probably wont understand what I am talking about as most informed people would.”
by CharlieDodd
Friday, October 26 2012, 1:46AM
“Incidentally I just visited the ThisisExeter website and this item caught my eye-
"Global coffee giant Starbucks has closed one of its Exeter city centre branches after six years of trading"..
Huh, so much for companies 'falling over themselves' to invest in Exeter..:)”
by CharlieDodd
Friday, October 26 2012, 1:38AM
“..Dunthiel said- 'No Charlie, the vast majority of tourists will ask 'where or what is Plymouth?'..
Only if they're from Mars mate..:)”
by pieter20133
Thursday, October 25 2012, 11:53PM
“Remember that Charlie lived in Leicester where he got shot at, his best job was a hotel porter, and he lives in a rented flat by himself, and votes UKIP so his ability to discuss economics is severely limited”
by Dunthiel
Thursday, October 25 2012, 10:56PM
“Urban motorways, such as the M4 through Newport and the M5 in Birmingham, are permitted to have lower standards (i.e. a tighter radius) than rural motorways. As you say these curved sections have advisory speed limits of 50mph so, even if an exception was made, it would be shooting ourselves in the foot to 'upgrade' the A38 to a motorway only to see numerous sections appear where we're advised to do 50.”
by b_mused
Thursday, October 25 2012, 9:56PM
“Dunthiel - The M4 motorway around Newport and Port Talbot has nasty bends and speed restrictions. Prefer the A38 to Exeter myself.”
by Dunthiel
Thursday, October 25 2012, 8:48PM
“No Charlie, the vast majority will ask 'where or what is Plymouth?'.
The UK receives around 30 million tourists per year, approximately 3 million of these are from the US with another half million from Canada. Plymouth receives approximately 25,000 overnight stays on the back of 75,000 annual visits from international tourists, but in reality these figures are skewed because they include some visits by overseas students studying here.
That is a staggeringly bad performance, considering the wealth of international history which Plymouth has to offer visitors from all corners of the world. But when you look at our road, rail and now non existent air links, it's not hard to see why.
If Plymouth attracted just 1% of this market, we would more than quadruple our annual international tourist numbers and the money they spend here.”
by CharlieDodd
Thursday, October 25 2012, 8:15PM
“Sure, little Exeter may have an agenda of encouraging business investment at the moment, so if it wants to become one vast business park or truck stop it's none of my business..:)
But ask any tourist arriving at Heathrow where they intend going, and Plymouth will be high on their list because of it's fame (Mayflower/Lt John Chard of Zulu/Scott of the Antarctic/Lawrence of Arabia/Drake/Raleigh/Cattedown Caveman/Eddystone Light/Marines/Royal Navy/The Hoe/The Sound etc, etc)
By comparison, poor little Exeter has got nowt”
by timplymouth
Thursday, October 25 2012, 7:44PM
“So where are they Charlie? Something is driving investment away from Plymouth and towards Exeter. We can all see this. Plymouth has nothing but a Naval base and a University.”
by CharlieDodd
Thursday, October 25 2012, 7:20PM
“..Tim said- 'Poor transport links will discourage investment in Plymouth'..
I'm sure no investor worth his salt would miss the business potential of setting up in a big world-famous city of 260,000 people like Plymouth.
Civilisation doesn't end at little Exeter (population 120,000) as most people think, it's simply a gateway to Plymouth and the whole of Cornwall beyond..:)”