MP tackles post office minister over 'perverse' closure plans

Trusted article source icon
Friday, July 04, 2008
Profile image for This is Plymouth

This is Plymouth

PLANS to shut post offices in Plymouth have been branded 'perverse' at Westminster.

Labour MP for Plymouth Sutton Linda Gilroy tackled Post Office Minister Pat McFadden in the Commons over the move to shut branches in her constituency.

A six-week public consultation into the controversial proposals ended this week, and the fate of the threatened branches is expected to be finalised in the coming weeks.

Under the plans, South West Devon is also set to see five branches axed, including Underwood Post Office in Plympton.

The closures form part of a radical Government overhaul of the network, which will see 2,500 branches shut across the country.

The Government argues four million fewer people a week are using post offices than just two years ago, and the network loses £3.5million a week.

Ministers point out that £1.7billion of subsidy is being made available to maintain the remaining network.

However, during a Parliamentary debate secured on the city closure plans, Mrs Gilroy argued the Post Office had got it wrong in Plymouth.

Viable branches were being closed in the city, which had ambitious regeneration plans and was set to see 30,000 new homes built in the next two decades, she said.

In the Commons this week, Mrs Gilroy again challenged the minister over the proposals, saying: “When we have a Devon cluster that includes one of the most sparsely-populated counties in the country together with an urban area with some of the most deep-seated poverty, perverse proposals emerge, such as the closures of Pennycomequick, Beaumont Road and St Levan Valley post offices.

“Does he really think he is getting value for money from the £1.7billion when it produces such perverse proposals to close busy post offices?”

Responding, Mr McFadden said: “She has made her point, and it is clear she believes it is wrong for her city to be in the same closure plan as a major rural area such as the county of Devon. Of course, that has happened in several places around the country where urban and rural areas have been combined for this purpose.

“It is difficult, but the access criteria are intended to ensure that we have a stable network for the future in both rural and urban areas.”

9
Tweet this article
Report

9 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by M Cook, Llanwrda

    Sunday, July 06 2008, 4:25PM

    “I never thought i would say this but its a SHAME that Royal mail wasn't privatised from the start. Because then maybe some decent shareholders would do something about the way they are treating people. The ONLy shareholder is Government but it sits back and let's RM get away with whatever it likes. MPs as stakeholders will do nothing about post offices closures all they are interested in is keeping money in the national purse for kitchens, expenses oh and £3 million payouts to their mates at Royal mail. Shame on them all.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Sgt.Candy, Coxside

    Sunday, July 06 2008, 8:03AM

    “Molly get a life you sad woman, Gilroy is a fake just like the rest of the Labour party”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by post man pat, on the dole

    Saturday, July 05 2008, 10:32PM

    “where were you all when i said me and my cat would suffer because you are all using email ( such as this ) to write ? . cat food is now up by 40% !”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by C22 ROCKS, uk

    Saturday, July 05 2008, 9:08PM

    “The government is presiding over the wanton destruction of the UK Post Office network- hundreds of closures in addition to privatising Royal Mail by the back door.

    All we've seen is a reduction in quality of service, increases in prices, and a lessening of pay, terms and conditions, benefits and pensions for all those employed in the UK postal industry.

    New Labour- not for labour”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Molly, sutton

    Saturday, July 05 2008, 8:01PM

    “well , i for one will still vote for her. she is my inspiration in life and for my comments on here.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Jan, south west

    Saturday, July 05 2008, 4:42PM

    “Labour got though the last election by using the slogan say no to privatisation, but then backed the plan of opening the business to commercial freedom ? too late now to save the Post Offices, you let them go a long time ago, its no good using the closures as a plan for your next campaign, because you have already sold them down the river !!”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Micky, Eggbuckland

    Saturday, July 05 2008, 4:17PM

    “GILROY SUPPORTS LOCAL POST OFFICES?!?!? When did this conversion take place? Not when voting on the bill in the House Commons, that's for sure. A simple inspection of New Labour wasters voting records will quickly dispel any of her desperate vote buying antics. Gilroy must think this is the 18th century when MPs could get away with lying about matters like this - not any more, dear. We can easily find out whether your words are empty, whatever the subject may be: from closing local POs to "John Lewis" expense claim details. Perhaps you should have thought about your constituents (like you're meant to do) back when all was rosy in the Pro-rich and Pro-foreigner Labour party instead of voting as instructed by the Blair, Brown or the Whips. But what can we expect after 11 years of ultra-Tory New Labour? Never mind, the electorate will soon WIPE New Labour off the political map forever - then coming 5th behind the Greens and the BNP will look like Christmas has come early... for everyone.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by shirley, plymouth

    Saturday, July 05 2008, 12:33PM

    “I cant believe this headline! Linda Gilroy you voted for the post offices to close!! Changing your colours to hold on to your seat!! You aren't fooling anybody with your comments. We the public know that this is all just a stunt so you get noticed more in the commons. Did anybody actually see Linda Gilroys fight for the Post Offices in the Live at the commons? She has 3 people listening to her and it wasnt even a debate in the commons, just in some vacant hall! Empty words, Empty promises.....”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Me, Plymouth

    Saturday, July 05 2008, 10:27AM

    “Nobody moaned when postage stamps started to be sold in supermarkets pay by phone, pensions paid by direct payment etc etc ..surely this was the first step leading to closures of many post offices it don`t take a brain surgeon to work that out surely !”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters