Man threw bottles of wine from rooftop during four-hour stand-off
A MAN with mental health problems climbed on to the roof of flats in Stonehouse and dropped bottles of wine on to the ground below during a four-hour stand-off, a court heard.
Plymouth Magistrates' Court was told that 29-year-old David Dunwell sat on top of flats in St Mary Street while police tried to talk him down.
Dunwell, of St Pancras Avenue in Pennycross, admitted threatening behaviour on July 17.
Michael French, for the Crown Prosecution Service, said that Dunwell had been drinking heavily after taking medication for a mental health condition.
He added that Dunwell told police he had not slept for four days.
Mr French said that Dunwell climbed up on to the roof of St Mary Street flats in Stonehouse 'with a bottle of wine in both hands'.
He added: "He then started to throw the bottles down."
Mr French said that police negotiators spent four hours trying to talk him down.
Roger Page, for Dunwell, said that he was under the care of a community psychiatric nurse.
He added that he was depressed after splitting from his wife and heard voices telling him to climb on to the roof.
Mr Page said that instead of calling the out-of-hours psychiatric team he started drinking. He added that he was suicidal on the roof and repeatedly threatened to throw himself off.
District judge Paul Farmer told Dunwell that he had caused the police a lot of 'cost and concern' after taking alcohol on top of his medication.
But he added that he had spent a weekend in custody and was already receiving psychiatric help.
Mr Framer imposed a conditional discharge of 12 months.








5 Comments
by Shipmate Ron, Plymouth
Wednesday, July 21 2010, 8:55PM
“Is that a cry for help C?”
by C, Plymouth
Wednesday, July 21 2010, 7:53PM
“Years ago they closed the mental Homes and let people with mental problems out, promising that they would be monitored to be sure they took their medication, this is obviously not happening, these people can't cope on their own, the only option is to send them to prison which is obviously not the answer, these people need constant supervision and help”
by Boris Napper, Eddystone lighthouse
Wednesday, July 21 2010, 2:51PM
“This brings tears to my eyes. It's by far the worst case of alcohol abuse I've known in ages.
He should be shot.”
by GRIBBLE, EXETER
Wednesday, July 21 2010, 11:37AM
“The Cop's should have thrown that lowlife off --done us all a favour.”
by Edward Cutty-Dyer, Aahburton Devon
Wednesday, July 21 2010, 10:43AM
“I think he was totally insane
as he kept shouting that Argyle would beat Exeter City.”