BREAKING NEWS
 

Plymouth judge says we should look at legalising drugs

Trusted article source icon
Monday, December 05, 2011
Profile image for Plymouth Herald

Plymouth Herald

A JUDGE has called for policy-makers to look at whether drugs should be legalised – saying that the war on drugs is being lost.

District judge Paul Farmer said that money was being wasted prosecuting addicts when they should be getting help to kick the habit.

  1. paulfarmer

    Paul Farmer

Mr Farmer, who has sentenced scores of addicts, said it would be better to treat them with prescriptions and prosecute dealers.

He said: "I would be one of the people who is not convinced that it is of any great benefit to make the use of drugs a criminal offence.

Business Cards From Only £10.95 Delivered www.myprint-247.co.uk

myprint-247

View details

Print voucher

Our heavyweight cards have FREE UV silk coating, FREE next day delivery & VAT included. Choose from 1000's of pre-designed templates or upload your own artwork. Orders dispatched within 24hrs.

Terms: Visit our site for more products: Business Cards, Compliment Slips, Letterheads, Leaflets, Postcards, Posters & much more. All items are free next day delivery. www.myprint-247.co.uk

Contact: 01858 468192

Valid until: Friday, May 31 2013

"I would much rather all those who are detected are dealt with by means of prescription, so that the whole time they use they are monitored.

"Then there is a chance of monitoring their use and bringing that use down and they have not got to steal to use.

"All the police's efforts should be directed towards the suppliers.

"We are wasting an inordinate amount of money: the police, the courts and in legal aid."

Mr Farmer, aged 64, who has just retired after nine years as Devon and Cornwall's district judge, has sentenced scores of people for possession of drugs or for theft to fund their addictions.

He has also reviewed dozens of Drug Rehabilitation Requirements, six-month court orders which test and treat defendants for their habits.

Heroin users are typically given a reducing prescription of methadone to wean them from the drug.

Many addicts are caught in a cycle of addiction and offending to fund their habits, with some making dozens of court appearances for possession and theft. Many go to jail for short periods but do not stop committing crime.

Mr Farmer said more resources could also be freed up to persuade young people not to start using drugs.

He added: "I do not think the current system is working, that is not the answer. It is time to look at a prescription system so that those people who are using are actively using in the community.

"They will be better assisted to come off the drugs.

"The main aim of sentencing tends to get them off drugs, so why not start at that point in the first place?"

He said sending offenders to prison was a 'last resort' – and was almost always for people who had previously breached community orders.

Mr Farmer said every single heroin user he dealt with had similar problems.

He added: "They have issues with housing, issues with benefit and if they are living in hostels, they are living with people with exactly the same problem.

"It is a chance to do something new. I think there is a chance it could be more successful than the current system."

Mr Farmer said that addicts had so many deep-seated problems a court sentence tended to be just a 'finger in the dyke'.

Asked whether he thought drugs should be legalised, Mr Farmer said: "I am not a politician. It is a matter for Parliament. We need a better way of dealing with it."

"I just believe we are not winning the war at the moment and it might be time to look at a different approach."

Mr Farmer praised the work of agencies which work together in Plymouth to tackle drug abuse and related crime. He is to become a trustee of Hamoaze House, a drug rehabilitation centre.

The former district judge for Essex, Kevin Gray, has taken Mr Farmer's role in Devon and Cornwall.

Comment – Page 10

0
Tweet this article
Report

Comments

  • Profile image for stevester8308

    by stevester8308

    Wednesday, December 07 2011, 12:21PM

    “Your replys only show people here how stupid you are Hamlynt , you havnt even tried to combat one thing ive said with any facts as to why drugs should remain illegal so in turn you are proving my point correct about you and the drugs policy ( both are stupid ) . Then you label me as a loser , read back over your comments and you will see who the loser is , from the lack of facts you put forward and your use of insults instead , i think im the one thats hit a nerve .”

  • Profile image for MagicalOne

    by MagicalOne

    Wednesday, December 07 2011, 5:14AM

    “A woman I know , who lives in a small town in the middle of the countryside lost her son to a bad batch of heroin , it was his first time. He was sold or given the drug by a heroin addict who was ( as many are ) eager to find new customers in order to fund his/her own addiction . All you need is one heroin addict to enter a community an it isn't long before a chain reaction occurs and you have many heroin addicts seeking new customers in order to fund their habits, it is a contagion and we are not talking about criminals here these are just youngsters who can come from any family , yours included. My brother who was a police officer who conducted many drugs raids on addicts during his career ( mostly in small towns and villages ) when asked what help was available to these addicts to get off these drugs responded with; NONE . These youngsters are easy targets and can be raided by the police over and over again as they are ADDICTS and cannot live without these drugs and there is so very little help available to them . Heroin addicts can and do live very productive lives if they are ensured a safe supply , which was I believe once the case when heroin was available to them on prescription subject to the WAR on Drugs which began in the 1960's and the result of which is visible in every town and city and even villages of our country today , the war is lost , it is time to find a new approach or at least attempt a rational dialogue about the way forward, Switzerland , Portugal and Holland have already begun this debate and taken action , the result is far fewer young people becoming ensnared in the taking of drugs , there are now far fewer addicts in these countries which have become safer places for their children and their families on so many levels .”

  • Profile image for MagicalOne

    by MagicalOne

    Wednesday, December 07 2011, 5:02AM

    “@ Boris20111,
    yes Boris I am , in an ideal world there would be no addicts , this is not an ideal world therefore we need to address a world in which addiction is not only prevalent but rampant.
    We have been living with the alternative all our lives and there cannot be many families in the land who have not been touched by addiction within them and the pain and the heartache it brings to everyone concerned . Far better to allow an addict access to clean and quality controlled drugs dispensed with understanding and tolerance than for young women to be forced to patrol the streets in prostitution in search of enough money to feed their habits or for muggings and robberies of close family and indeed honest citizens going about there lives. Legalising and dispensing drugs ( I think particularly of heroin) would most assuredly cost society far less and could be purchased from the growers in Afghanistan for a pittance , cutting out the criminal gangs who make such profit from the very real human misery that I for one have observed from my own, once beautiful young cousins experiences . It is time for some humanity to be shown to these victims and to ourselves, the war on drugs has failed abysmally and we as a society can no longer afford to wage it , it makes no economic sense at all to do so.”

  • Profile image for Workitout

    by Workitout

    Tuesday, December 06 2011, 9:30PM

    “A "Cracking" Idea.
    Free drugs for the Legal People.
    Another reduction in their spending.
    And the "addicts" still have to rob houses.
    LOL”

  • Profile image for bandbunny

    by bandbunny

    Tuesday, December 06 2011, 8:36PM

    “I like to look at the positives of a story; so its nice to see that the government agree with the pushers in that drugs should remain illegal.”

  • Profile image for hamlynt

    by hamlynt

    Tuesday, December 06 2011, 7:47PM

    “Must have hit a raw nerve, his written a book - In bad England (Must be the drugs). It's so easy to get a response from this loser!!”

  • Profile image for stevester8308

    by stevester8308

    Tuesday, December 06 2011, 4:39PM

    “Hymlant says " but if you have a close family member or friend who OD's , or gets seriously hurt by someone high on drugs - just remember your very sad comments " . I know 2 people who were killed by drunk driver in a head on collision and i know a couple of alcoholics so i dont see your stupid point can you explain it to me Hymlant ! Is alcohol not legal and people die everyday because of it in some way or another so what is your point ?

    Then you say - " In fact im quite sure your making them up to get a response " - In nearly every post ive advised you to GOOGLE it for yourself and find out the facts on drugs on GOOGLE for yourself . So if you would have had he brains to actually look on Google then you would be " Quite sure " that i was telling the truth .

    Now for the black sheep bit Baaaaaaaaaa , im not the one who has came on here looking attention that is you . As ive said before i comment on these drug stories all the time and now and again you always get some ******* like yourself who posts pro prohibition **** because they = you are stupid enough to believe what you read in the papers where drugs are concerned .

    Then you have people like JOSDAVE , now this guy , has took the time to actually READ the story above and look at the FACTS and he posted a very sensible comment based on the FACTS and EVIDENCE . Now do you see how stupid you look Hymlant . I know if someone was making me look this stupid by always quoting the words " FACTS and EVIDENCE " id of gave up ****ging them and actually went and used Google to see the FACTS and EVIDENCE on drugs for myself , but in your case it looks like your too stupid to even use Google . Baaaaaaaaaaaa .”

  • Profile image for josdave

    by josdave

    Tuesday, December 06 2011, 3:50PM

    “The simple fact that more crime is committed because hard drugs are illegal seems to be a good case for legalising them. Look at America more alcohol was drunk during the prohibition period than was before or after. No-one forces these addicts to get started and there is enough publicity about the effects that they bring it on themselves if they choose to go down that road. Legalising drugs, so that those who need chemical stimulus to enjoy themselves could easily get them, would cut the crime rate at a stroke, put many dealers out of business, and raise tax revenue for the government. It's a win win.”

  • Profile image for hamlynt

    by hamlynt

    Tuesday, December 06 2011, 10:20AM

    “StevesterAGED3 - I wouldn't even wish it on you, but if you have a close family member or friend who OD's, or gets killed or serious hurt by someone high on drugs - Just remember your very sad comments. In fact I'm quite sure you are making them up to get a response, just after a bit of attention and likes to be the center of attention. Was most probably the black sheep of the family. I think 'Workitout' has summed you up quite well, but I would add on 'Cheesy' on the front of it.”

  • Profile image for kirtsy

    by kirtsy

    Monday, December 05 2011, 11:58PM

    “I agree that nicotine and alcohol are equally as bad however two wrongs dont make a right. http://tinyurl.com/cb2v5h2

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Be the first to comment

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article