Police force could axe 300 officers

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, August 06, 2009
Profile image for This is Plymouth

This is Plymouth

DEVON and Cornwall Police could be forced to axe 300 officers if the Government's multi-billion-pound banking bailout results in public spending being slashed.

The force fears that policing would be hit hardest if ministers decide to protect spending on health and education while having to pay for loans used to support the ailing banking industry.

Those concerns have resulted in an unprecedented letter from Chief Constable Stephen Otter and Mike Bull, chairman of the Devon and Cornwall Police Authority, to the region's MPs to rally support and lobbying power. Funding has been guaranteed until 2010/11, but not beyond.

In a stark nine-point briefing note they warned that a freeze in police grant in 2011/12 coupled with a 3 per cent increase in council tax levy would require savings of £11 million.

"In order to get a feel for the potential scale of the problem, saving say £10 million from police officer pay would be equivalent to losing some 300 police officers," they wrote.

The force, which currently boasts 3,500 officers, has undergone major change in recent years. Some 250 civilian back-office posts have been lost – around 10 per cent – allowing a further 200 officers to be transferred to the frontline. While making multi-million-pound savings year-on-year, the restructuring has delivered results, with overall crime falling and public confidence in the police rising. This year's police grant was £186 million.

"We have consistently delivered above-target savings and have shifted considerable resources from back-office functions to the front line," Mr Otter and Mr Bull told MPs. "In spite of this record, we are fearful that possible future restrictions on public spending could mean it is impossible to sustain officer numbers and could mean a major and continued setback for front-line policing." A senior team has already been appointed by the force to plan for a variety of budget scenarios in 2011/12. They have been briefed to "think the unthinkable".

Any job losses among officers could not be delivered by "natural wastage" and freezing recruitment. Senior police sources said ministers and Whitehall officials were currently unwilling to discuss future budgets, with no-one breaking ranks. It is unclear whether a department-by-department, comprehensive spending review will be held before the next general election, likely to be May 2010.

"There has been much debate on the problems of public sector spending and the need to constrain spending to bring debt levels down after the recession," the briefing went on. "No doubt there will be much more over the coming months. However, many commentators agree that the financial and economic crisis will lead to major constraints on public spending over the next two to five years.

"So far, different speakers have talked of protecting health or, perhaps, education. There is a real danger that, in these debates, policing could be treated merely as part of 'other public spending' – a sector that is likely to face the most severe constraints, especially if it also has to cover the real and growing cost of servicing public sector debt.

"The purpose of this note is to remind members that there are real and pressing demands for policing, demands which cannot be met if resources for policing are frozen or reduced. We are dependent on council tax and, crucially, police grant.

"We believe our strategy here in Devon and Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly to drive up the number of police officers and to enhance front-line policing is what local communities want and is entirely consistent with Government policy. Enhanced policing has been and is a success.

"It would be most unfortunate if this success was to be undermined by spending constraints in a public spending round dominated by the big spenders of health, education and debt."

The approach met a mixed response from MPs. Gary Streeter, Tory MP for South West Devon, said the police should resist "whingeing" and instead concentrate on modernising the way they work.

"Every department is going to have to tighten its belt in the next few years – that's the reality," he said. "I think there are lots of ways the police – who I have huge respect for – could look to do things better, particularly in the management.

"They could learn colossal things from the private sector. They are still stuck in the dark ages in terms of technology."

He added: "It is no good just whingeing because whingeing will get you nowhere. There will be no special pleading if there is a Conservative government."

Senior police sources have suggested they fear the commitment by both Labour and the Conservatives to protect health spending was unfair. One insider said: "It will leave the health service just as unfit as it is now."

Geoffrey Cox, Tory MP for Torridge and West Devon, said: "If the chief constable is very concerned that the financial allocation to them is going to be insufficient to keep their front-line officers at full strength, that would be a very, very retrograde and disappointing outcome if that is true."

A Home Office spokesman said the police funding formula was "designed to make sure that all forces, regardless of whether they are rural or urban, are adequately resourced". He said there had been a 60 per cent increase in funding for police since 1997 and added that police numbers were at an all-time high.

"In addition, the Rural Police Fund provides extra funding to help rural forces meet their unique policing priorities, increasing both the visibility of police officers in rural communities and the public's access to them."

27
Tweet this article
Report

27 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by jockmcspedder, Plymouth

    Thursday, August 06 2009, 10:29PM

    “Private sector example of reducing costs?? Cops drive Volvo & BMW & Range Rovers like reps in BMWs/ Audis. Bring back the Morris Minor Panda.
    Ever see a cop walking around on his own these days? Two people doing one person's work. How many deputies does one chief constable need? There has always been a waste of resources. Some years ago I couldn't raise anyone at the local cop shop because there was only one officer there. In which case why were there 2 pandas and a motor-bike parked around the back? If she was unable to leave her desk even to answer the door, then she had no need for transport. She could have been dropped off and collected later freeing 3 vehicles which we pay for in the expectation that they would be used and not parked at an almost deserted police station. Multiply this kind of waste by how many police stations?”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by David Mavin, Eggbuckland

    Thursday, August 06 2009, 9:09PM

    “If this funding debate was being aired 12 months ago then I think that Mr Streeter would have been criticising the Labour ineptitude, but with the election less than a year away and the prospect of a Tory government on the horizon, he knows it will be his executive that will be making the decisions.
    I do take umbrage with the stereotypical Tory outlook that lessons can be learnt from private sector management as the grass is not always greener (the banking crisis was a product of private sector management), also how much more money is this country going to spend on the latest technology which will be outdated in 6 months (again feeding the large multi-national corporations).
    Is the Tory mantra not Bobbies on the beat or are we on the brink of employing Robocop.

    A thought;

    The dockyard was privatised by the last Tory government in an attempt to create a competitive market, now we have both dockyards owned by the same company effectively forming a monopoly, last year Babcock Marine posted pre tax profits of £147M.
    My point is that potentially £100M of this profit (the majority made in this city) could have provided 4000 jobs if the wage was £25K pa rather than indulge the shareholders in the city of London.
    Wages that could have employed police, nurses, social services, fire-fighters and apprentices¿ to name a few, when are we going to put communities and people before international companies and profits.

    VfM”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Mick, Brbican

    Thursday, August 06 2009, 7:28PM

    “M quote- "Mick there's far more home grown scroungers than imported ones!"

    Ah, but our home-grown ones "are native here, and to the manor born" (Hamlet), so they should get priority..;)”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by M, Plymouth

    Thursday, August 06 2009, 7:17PM

    “If drugs were legalized and taxed there would be enough money to justify a police recruitment drive rather than culling...
    This will end in tears...many tears from many different people for a very long time...
    Mick there's far more home grown scroungers than imported ones!”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by martyn, plymouth

    Thursday, August 06 2009, 6:29PM

    “3,500 seems rather a lot of policeman for just Devon & Cornwall. And they have that mass of much cheaper foot pad PCSOs.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Jessica, The Millfields

    Thursday, August 06 2009, 6:27PM

    “With crime figures plummeting it seems like a reasonable economy.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Reg, Saint Judes

    Thursday, August 06 2009, 5:54PM

    “No need to axe them, thats a bit harsh, why not use the tazer instead, apparently its harmless.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Mick, Barbican

    Thursday, August 06 2009, 5:44PM

    “Why do the words 'axe' and 'Labour government' always seem to go together, whether they're talking about axing dockyards, the armed services, military spending, the police and whatever?
    On second thoughts I suppose they have to make cuts to free up cash to hand out to asylum seekers.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Gordon Loves Big Business..., Plymouth

    Thursday, August 06 2009, 5:18PM

    “It's New Labour's fixation with Big Business.

    When Big Business runs the Country what do we need elections for? Why pay MPs if it's Big Business running the UK.

    Ah well perhaps some of those 300 police could get jobs building polluting Cold War suitable Eurofighters?

    More weapons we'll never be able to use! Ah well, they'll keep people in work and profits in BAe and the like.”

  • Profile image for This is Plymouth

    by Teddy Bing Bong, Bing Bong Land

    Thursday, August 06 2009, 4:36PM

    “Why is it the emergency service key workers pay for the greed and negligence of the private sector in the bad times yet never reap any of the rewards during the good?

    This country needs to seriously get it's priorities in order as health, education, crime and defence are all areas that are over stretched and under resourced as it is.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters