Peter Reid could take direct way ahead after disappointing loss to Torquay United
PLYMOUTH Argyle manager Peter Reid admits he might have to depart from his ideal football philosophy if he is to get the best out of the current first-team squad.
Reid said he may cut his Green cloth accordingly after watching Argyle lose 3-1 to their League Two neighbours Torquay United in what he called a 'disappointing' performance at Plainmoor.
-

And while he accepted that there is plenty of time to go before the start of the League One season, certain aspects of his team's display on Tuesday night provided plenty of food for thought.
The former Sunderland boss tried out a 4-3-3 formation in attack, reverting to 4-5-1 when the opposition were in possession, which he said did not quite go according to plan.
"I want to play a passing game but if we can't do it I've got to change it," said Reid.
"We might have to go earlier up to the front man and get support up there. We lost the ball too many times in midfield areas and they were at us. It wasn't great.
"Even though it was a friendly I don't particularly like getting beaten in games.
"But I thought the better team won. I thought Torquay were hungrier and wanted it more than us.
"There's no excuse for that. It was just basics. Besides them looking fitter I don't think we passed the ball."
Things began well for Argyle against Torquay, with Craig Noone getting on the end of a Chris Barker cross in the second minute to put them ahead. But with Torquay equalising before half-time and scoring two unanswered goals after the break, Reid was not entirely happy with what followed.
He said: "We started well and got a really good goal but after that our passing went and our shape went and to be fair they looked a lot stronger and fitter than us.
"I know there's a long way to go to the start of the season. One of the good things about today is that it is today and not the first game of the season.
"It's a friendly and I made so many changes that you're not going to get any continuity. But we worked on shape and our shape completely went and I've got to say they did look stronger from a physical point of view.
"I've got plenty of things to work on but I'm really disappointed in certain aspects of our play."
Reid introduced two triallists during the friendly, with Bermudan goalkeeper Freddy Hall replacing Romain Larrieu in the first half after the Frenchman reported a slight groin strain.
In the second half he took off Steve MacLean and replaced him with a mystery striker, now understood to have been Manuel Mence, a 22-year-old Martinique international, once of SC Amiens who play in the French third tier.
Hall's first real act was to pick the equaliser out of his net and he was a little at fault for the Gulls' second, while Mence failed to make much of an impression up front.
Reid said: "[Manuel] is just a French boy who's come over, who's out of contract. We're just having a look at him.
"And Romain had just done his groin so I didn't want it to get any worse. I thought [Hall] was a bit rash for the goal, but he's a young kid and one we're just having a look at."
Reid admits he is constantly learning about his new squad and will try to give each of them a fair crack of the whip on their pre-season training camp in Holland, for which they depart tomorrow.
"I'm giving everyone a look," he said. "We have got a sprinkling of experience and a lot of young players and I'm just giving everyone games and seeing how they go.
"I'm learning a lot about the players and sometimes you learn an awful lot in defeat. I certainly did this evening.
"I'm not pleased with the result or the performance, but I'm pleased I've got something out of it. It taught me a lot about the players."
One of those from whom Reid had requested more effort since his arrival was MacLean, who put in a decent shift up front alongside new signing Rory Patterson before being replaced by Mence in the 63rd minute.
"I thought [MacLean] started really well," said Reid. "He was bright, he got on it, but I thought he faded, so that wasn't long enough in the saddle. But he has got ability."
Argyle open their three-match tour of Holland against NAC Breda this Saturday, before meeting AZ Alkmaar on July 21 and SC Cambuur the day after.
They return home for friendlies against Hereford United away on July 28, before travelling to Loftus Road to play Neil Warnock's QPR on July 30, and finally Saltash United at Kimberley Stadium on August 2.








19 Comments
View all
by ian ashford, King's Lynn
Thursday, July 15 2010, 10:15PM
“Oh, do we miss Olly. I told you back then and I was right. He was the best manager we had for many many years to certainly take us to the top. But it's an expensive gamble that the board were not going to take. You can't blame them, to a degree, but you can lay the blame at their door for the fiasco with keeping Sturrock on far, far too long though.
Peter Reid? Well, early days. The good thing is that he, like Olly, is good in front of the camera and is PR savvy. Appointed as a plus point for the World Cup bid, maybe???
Anyway, I was amused by the fact that he was upset by not being able to play passing football... oh no, not again I thought. It's gonna be a hoof it up field season again to Rory and let the rest of his teammates of restricted height sort out the loose ball. That's are key problem. The only good thing about this is that it does work in the lower league. It doesn't work so effectively in the Championship and Premiership because you have a tall, physically strong back 4 to win the ball.
Mr Reid has a shabby rag tag of a team, a broken army, and has a great deal of work to do.
I wish him all the best and to be honest I think he will give it a good go and be moderately successful. Promotion? Well, that is all down to instilling belief in his team. Just look what happened to the players on £150K a week, playing for England. The players have to believe. Good luck to Mr Reid and all those at PAFC.”
by David, Plymouth
Thursday, July 15 2010, 8:10PM
“Geoff - what makes someone who takes a different view to you a moron?
Unless I've lost the ability to interpret the english language there is very little "slagging off" here - most people are expressing a genuine concern that we are in danger of repeating last season's mistakes.
Yes it's early days but last year we started cr@p, carried on cr@p and ended up being relegated.”
by Davy, Devonport End
Thursday, July 15 2010, 7:48PM
“@ keith crewe - Oi
Davy!”
by Geoff, Plymouth
Thursday, July 15 2010, 6:42PM
“It's early days yet.
Why don't you get behind+ encourage Argyle instead of slagging them off
MORONS!!!!”
by Jan, South West
Thursday, July 15 2010, 6:16PM
“Chris Barker is the best player we have at Plymouth ! why !”
by Robinho, PLYMOUTH
Thursday, July 15 2010, 5:40PM
“Yes Chris Barker has been told he can go which has paved the way for Tony Capaldi to make his Home Park return. Good luck to Tony he is a good player who has won promotion with us before, rather have him than Chris Barker but any way good luck Chris, hope you find a decent new club!”
by keith crewe, plymouth
Thursday, July 15 2010, 5:17PM
“Capaldi training with Argyle after being released by Cardiff? Not seen anything in the local press?”
by David, St Austell
Thursday, July 15 2010, 4:37PM
“Let's hope last nights game was not a rehearsal for a league game against Torquay next year.”
by David, Plymouth
Thursday, July 15 2010, 4:11PM
“Seems that Chris Barker has been told he can leave and we have Tony Capaldi on trial.”
by zorba the green, plymouth
Thursday, July 15 2010, 11:51AM
“I totally agree with David of Plymouth, this board has no real interest in the Football club. The recent appointment was a bodge because he was willing to work with Mariner.
Just over a year ago a certain manager went to Blackpool who were at the time a basket case, hit the ground running. With a few additions and coaching the team how to play good football secured premiership football. I have not seen evidence of Peter Reid hitting the ground running and Plymouth still look a disorganised rabble with half of the team that could not trap a bag of cement or string two passes together.
The direct way, isn¿t that how we played with Sturrock and how we were relegated?
It is obvious the present players are not good enough as is the manager and coaching staff. Get rid of the lot them and bring in people that are capable of doing the job otherwise we will end up in the conference league.”