School gets turbines after three-year battle

Trusted article source icon
Friday, January 30, 2009
Profile image for This is Cornwall

This is Cornwall

A PLYMOUTH school is celebrating after finally installing wind turbines on its campus after a bitter three-year dispute.

Coombe Dean School in Plymstock said it had taken a major step in reducing its carbon footprint with the 20 metre-high structures.

The wind turbines will also be used to educate students about how to take care of the environment.

The school admitted that the scheme had met 'determined and vociferous opposition from local residents', and it was refused permission by the city council.

Neighbours branded the turbines an eyesore, claimed they would make too much noise and were worried about the flickering from the whirring blades. Some even feared a blade could snap off and cause an accident.

However, the school took the application to a planning appeal and an inspector decided in November to grant permission.

"I consider that, on balance, the limited visual harm would be clearly outweighed by the practical benefits to the school and the wider environmental, economic and social benefits," he said.

The school said the turbines would meet between 20 and 25 per cent of its electricity needs and save up to 30 tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions every year.

However, staff added that the main benefit of the turbines would be to inspire and educate the pupils.

The school already has other environmental energy sources: solar panels on the roof and a ground source heating pump.

Data from the turbines will be loaded on to the school's IT network and used in lessons, alongside that from Coombe Dean's other energy sources.

Headteacher Pattrick Frean said: "Most people, including our own students, are wondering what the fuss was about. They look at the turbines and say, 'Is that it?'.

"The turbines are in keeping with the size of the school buildings."

203
Tweet this article
Report

203 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Phil, Plymstock

    Sunday, March 08 2009, 8:26PM

    “Simon has a typical Coombe Dean attitude. Next, simon, we get them isolated. I see Coombe Dean have cut some trees down, I wonder if they will report that in their school mag.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Doris, Plymstock

    Sunday, March 08 2009, 1:47PM

    “Turbines are very loud again today. We¿ve added date and time to our noise nuisance diary and also taken a video recording. The turbine noise is a lot higher than the general background noise.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Margaret, Elburton

    Sunday, March 08 2009, 12:11PM

    “Coombe Dean Parent. If I had the time and money I would love to protest about all the wind turbines that are incorrectly located. As it is, I live next to CDS and that concerns me the most. What a strange way to argue your case ¿ just because NMA have incorrectly located their turbine doesn¿t mean that CDS should do the same. I really don¿t understand your attitude. These things are dangerous! Why are you prepared to risk your childs safety. Are you going to wait for an accident to occur before you face reality.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by W A S T E O F M O N E Y, Plymstock

    Sunday, March 08 2009, 10:26AM

    “Very loud today, just what the Environmental Health people need. Interesting comment by "Coombe Dean Parent" stating that the school has legally erected the Turbines, he seems to have missed out the bit about, "they shall be no louder than 5 decibels above background noise to the nearest dwelling", that quite clearly will be coombe deans downfall. Bring it on.”

  • Profile image for This is Cornwall

    by Coombe Dean Parent, Plymstock

    Saturday, March 07 2009, 6:51PM

    “Margaret, I refer to my original question. If they are so dangerous, what protestation have you made with regard to the turbines situated at the National Marine Aquarium? Surely with the stronger winds in the Barbican area they are more likely to disintegrate and kill passers-by? I expect none. Your protestations are aimed solely at the school because you do not like what they have legally done. If it were about Public safety you would have protested the now 3 year old turbines long ago.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article