Calls for radical action as widening gap between rich and poor in city is laid bare

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, February 24, 2011
Profile image for This is Devon

This is Devon

PLYMOUTH'S poorest residents die almost 15 years younger than the richest, according to figures revealing stark inequalities between neighbourhoods.

The widening gap in life expectancy is laid bare in a report published today by the city's director of public health.

It also shows shockingly higher rates of smoking in pregnancy, teenage pregnancy, childhood tooth decay and obesity in the city's deprived areas.

A child born in Devonport is expected to live to an average of 72.2 years, compared to 86.9 in Widewell. The gap of 14.7 years has increased from 12 since the previous year's estimate.

While 39 per cent of mums in Whitleigh smoke during pregnancy, the figure is 0 per cent in Glenholt and Woodford.

More than half of Barne Barton children have experienced tooth decay, compared to none in Glenholt and Widewell.

In Devonport, one in four children are obese. But Glenholt is recorded as having a 0 per cent obese children.

Debra Lapthorne, director of public health for Plymouth, said it is "unjust" that life is being "stolen" from the city's most disadvantaged residents.

She issued a rallying cry for city leaders to redouble efforts to tackle inequalities – in the face of major public spending cuts and NHS restructuring.

Ms Lapthorne said: "People are having time stolen from them because of the circumstances in which they live.

"The 14.7 years is a staggering amount of time to be snatched away from individuals and their families. They are dying before their time from things we could change."

She said the fact that the difference is based on people's social circumstances – where they are living, their opportunities and relative wealth – is "absolutely unjust".

"We are in the worst possible economic situation nationally, we are faced with swingeing cuts to services, we've got rising unemployment and an increasing life expectancy gap," she said.

"We either chose to do the same as we've done before – batten down the hatches, cut lots of services and protect our own. Or we chose as a city to address the underlying problems.

"Creating a fairer society in Plymouth is fundamental to improving the health of everyone in the city and ensuring that good health is not just the preserve of the rich."

Life expectancy has improved overall in Plymouth since 1997, she said.

The city's early death rates from cancer, heart disease and stroke have fallen in the past 10 years and continue to improve year on year.

Plymouth has also brought down smoking rates and increased breast feeding rates but huge inequalities between neighbourhoods persist.

"The national stats show that the gap is widening everywhere," said Ms Lapthorne. "It's gone in the wrong direction despite us improving some of the things that contribute to it.

"Health inequalities in Plymouth are, however, not inevitable and can be significantly reduced. They stem from avoidable inequalities in society – of income, education, employment and neighbourhood circumstances."

She stressed that focus must stay on reducing inequalities, promoting growth and raising aspirations as budget cuts bite, and services are reshaped.

Local councils face reduced funding and the NHS in Plymouth is looking to make £66 million worth of efficiency savings alongside massive structural changes.

When primary care trusts are scrapped in 2013, public health departments will moved from the NHS to councils – but have been promised a ring-fenced budget.

Ms Lapthorne said: "Partners will need to maintain their commitment to tackling inequalities and improving health through the turbulent times ahead and this will challenge us all.

"We know that local authorities nationally are looking to reduce funding for things like the Healthy Schools programme, which the Government has cut the grant for.

"Local authorities are having to make some very serious decisions and are trying to ensure that vulnerable people are protected."

Ms Lapthorne states in the report that Plymouth intends to become an "early implementer" of the proposed Health and Wellbeing Board to oversee a new public health strategy for the city.

She says this will "re-engage all partners in commitment and action to tackle health inequalities".

She said the last great health advance in the past 150 years was when Government cleared slums and provided better sanitation. The city needs a "radical shift" in implementing change, said Ms Lapthorne.

"A shift in thinking is needed," she explained.

"Government always sets out big changes and gets focused down on to smaller things, losing focus on larger societal changes.

"If we are going to tackle public health inequality, it's about changing the lot for local people.

"It needs to be on the scale of the Devonport New Deal for Communities project where they have transformed housing and education."

One of the main factors which causes preventable ill health and inequalities is smoking, she added.

"It's not just about information, we need to understand the culture of smoking in some of the most deprived neighbourhoods," she said.

"For example why women continue to smoke when they find out they are pregnant. Smoking in pregnancy is directly related to low birth rate, which is directly related to infant mortality. We need to find different ways of supporting women to make different choices."

Her report details work already being done to tackle issues by organisations including the NHS, council and joint bodies such as the Local Strategic Partnership.

Schemes including the Healthy Child and Healthy Schools programmes, sexual health initiatives, a young people's specialist substance misuse treatment service, the Stop Smoking Service, breastfeeding projects and community dental health promotion.

The report lays out six objectives published in an independent review 'Fair Society, Healthy Lives', which was commissioned by Government to tackle inequalities across the country.

They are to give every child the best start in life, enable all young people and adults to maximise their capabilities and have control over their lives, create fair employment and good work for all, ensure healthy standard of living for all, create and develop healthy and sustainable places and communities, strengthen the role and impact of ill health prevention. The report is due to be presented to health chiefs at today's NHS Plymouth board meeting.

How the figures stack up

PLYMOUTH'S annual public health report uses the following figures to demonstrate health inequalities for all ages:

More than one in three of Whitleigh's mums (39 per cent) smoke during

pregnancy, compared to Glenholt and Woodford where none do. The city

average is 18.5 per cent.

One in five (20 per cent) babies in

Tamerton are born with low birthweight, compared to none in Glenholt,

Chaddlewood and Turnchapel.

Ernesettle has the lowest

breastfeeding rate at six to eight weeks (10.5 per cent). Mutley and

Greenbank have the highest (56.3 per cent).

More than half (55.8

per cent) of Barne Barton children have experienced tooth decay. The

figure is zero in Glenholt and Widewell.

In Devonport, 26.2 per cent of children are obese, compared to zero per cent in Glenholt.

A teenager from Stonehouse is almost eight times more likely to become

pregnant than one from Plympton. The rate is 155.6/1,000 in Stonehouse

and 20.1/1,000 in Plympton.

35 per cent of families in Barne

Barton are classed as "vulnerable", compared to 1.2 per cent in

Chaddlewood. "Vulnerable" families are those who need extra support from

health or council services for a wide range of reasons including

unemployment disabilities, mental health problems or substance abuse

issues.

Ernesettle had the city's highest rate of emergency hospital admissions in 2009/10, while Hartley and Mannamead had the lowest.

The average life expectancy in Devonport is 72.2 years, and 86.9 in Widewell. The city average is 79.8 years.

You are 10 times more likely to die of a circulatory disease in Barne Barton than in Eggbuckland.

The eight most deprived Plymouth neighbourhoods are listed as

Devonport, Stonehouse, North Prospect, Barne Barton, Morice Town, East

End, Whitleigh and the city centre. The least deprived are Glenholt,

Plymstock, Goosewell, Colebrook and Newnham, Woodford, Hartley and

Mannamead, Elburton and Dunstone and Chaddlewood.

The list was

complied by NHS Plymouth's public health team in 2007, taking into

accounts factors including inadequate education and housing,

unemployment, income, poor health and low opportunities for enjoyment.

62
Tweet this article
Report

62 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by TOP GUN, UP UP AND AWAY!

    Saturday, February 26 2011, 2:31PM

    “I see the American eagle on the fourth picture has landed and has grounded herself for life!”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by mikethebike, plymouth

    Friday, February 25 2011, 6:50AM

    “Calls for radical action as widening gap between rich and poor in city is laid bare

    With the staggering hike in charges made by SWW today and yet to be reported by the Herald. The rich will be Rich & clean and the poor will be dirtier than normal??”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Brian, Mutley

    Friday, February 25 2011, 4:58AM

    “BabyLawyer, Mutley
    Sorry it does not wash with me, save the violins and the victim culture for some other mugs.
    I was the product of one parent family, outside toilet with no heating not that long ago when everyone had inside loo¿s, we had a broken shower once for over 12 mths, which meant either having a cold shower or washing in the sink, walk to school over 3 miles.
    No benefits, my mother worked, money was tight, I work away now as no jobs in Plymouth, Mondays I usually get up at 04:00am to hit the road, no sick pay or holiday pay in my line of work and like now until my next job time time off, albeit weeks or months, my choice, no one else to blame, no hard luck stories when looking for work, no debts, no smoking and not obese.
    Yes there are true unfortunates but that goes for any area, regrettably areas like Devonport, St Budeaux and Swilly have a victim culture and the world owes them a living philosophy, there are many hard working families and people there, but there are also a very high percentage of scum bags who play the system and social workers (more wasters) encourage this to keep themselves in jobs as do the good old Labour councillors and interesting enough a higher percentage of the Labour MP¿s will be serving time due to fiddling their expenses, interesting ¿ Animal Farm springs to mind.
    Remember all of us pick our own ways in life, lots of those choices can be down to luck, the right place at the right time, but the more you persistent you are the luckier you get, unfortunately whilst in some cases the benefits systems rewards are greater than work, then this culture will continue and as we have seen like simple house keeping the countries debts have been out of control under the previous clown party.
    We all know people on so called disabilities allowances that could take office jobs for example or are claiming for relatives or family members and using them as cash cows or single mums getting knocked up to get a flat and the golden life of benefits for 16 glorious years . And as for nature or nurture determining the result of our upbringing and the lack of the latter in these Labour run areas, their problem and choice, it goes on for generations.

    Sweet Lucy
    You seem to have too much time on your hands, why would I want to share with you, what I work hard for, get on your bike and get a job, stand up for yourself, do not try and share what is not yours, maybe try North Korea. What I have learnt and it does always make me laugh in most situations involving ¿Liebour¿ workers, its all for the people, yeah give us work, then when a select few have overtime or come into some money is it shared out ¿ NO”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by sweet lucy, plymouth england

    Friday, February 25 2011, 1:44AM

    “Perhaps we should make all those employed who think unemployed want to be there offer a job share half each we would soon see a change of attitude and maybe a bit more compassion you may know a few who dont want to work but if you really believe all on social dont want to work offer to share the job you have with us.Tories always cause unemployment it is in their D.N.A, the annoying thing to add insult to injury is they then tell us we dont want to work when in reality its to get us to work for less and be grateful to them the boss classes (tories) Viva la revolution.Because thats what they are provoking you can only deprive the masses so much something has to break the widening gap will become a issue that will be a trigger to unrest a level playing field must be top of the list stuff India S/Ireland charity begins at home.what idiot lends money to give away with no chance of getting it back when they are starving themselves.Cameron (clone of Thatcher) take note.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Stuart, Plymouth

    Friday, February 25 2011, 12:57AM

    “There used to be one Dave, I was born in it may years ago.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Dave, Plymouth

    Friday, February 25 2011, 12:30AM

    “Brilliant reporting by the Herald "A child born in Devonport....."
    If there's maternity hospital there it's well hidden.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Dick Barton, Plymouth

    Thursday, February 24 2011, 11:00PM

    “Look, I have worked in prisons, part of my work is now with the unemployed. I look down on no one and never have. I have been in the position of not knowing where the next penny is coming from. Some of the people I deal with have been dealt a bad hand, no doubt about it and some are where they are through stupidity. I don¿t claim everyone can pull themselves out of the situation they are in it takes a few things to do that. You need Lucky breaks, determination and a sense of purpose to name but three. The destruction of industry, our manufacturing base and communities by not just the Tory¿s but Labour also has much to answer for. It would have been cheaper in both social and monetary terms to keep our factories, pits and industries going instead of ripping the life and soul out of this country. These things gave people a sense of purpose and glued society, it wasn¿t perfect but for many it worked. We are groaning under the Burdon of mass immigration when we can¿t even find work for the people who are here already. I am not a racist and have travelled and don¿t care if you are black, green or blue. In fact I think while we have black this and race the other we create a society of division and inequality, we are either all equal and in this together or not. So-called positive discrimination with regard to race or sex benefits none and creates resentment. But I can tell you this, you are not in poverty if you can smoke, have a mobile or frequent the bars in Mutley or Union Street. When I was short of money feeding my family took priority over everything. Virtually every unemployed person or inmate I have ever met smokes. I don¿t care how much will power it takes to stop smoking, I did over twenty years ago, they can do it and use the money to feed their children. It would be a start.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by jockmcspredder, Plymouth

    Thursday, February 24 2011, 9:20PM

    “Alison - you have a very honeyed view of the BIG SOCIETY, don't you. The disabled are certainly a target of discrimination by the fiddlers and fraudsters in power. Is this what it really all boils down to?”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by BabyLawyer, Mutley

    Thursday, February 24 2011, 9:18PM

    “Brian - Mutley.

    'do you want us to say well done for getting a job, that's life'. - Um no what I want is for you to recognise the difficulties faced by those from lower income families.

    'submit to peer pressure and have no back bone' - I'm talking about children. Those which are the most impressionable. And that continues into their adult life. The majority of children do not have the confidence to stand up to peer-pressure and that is the time in which who they will be as an adult is being shaped. Some of us (luckily me) already had a sense of identity and knew what we wanted to do, but most do not.

    'stop blaming others' - Actually I will blame those who leave people in those conditions simply because they are unwilling to give them a chance. Many of these people want to work, want to do a good job, will be reliable and have skills which would be very useful. However, because they talk a certain way or look like a certain type of person they are discriminated against. It is rife throughout this country.

    'For being a write off' - And there is the view which causes so many people to continue staying down and not reaching further. How much more difficult would you find it to achieve anything if everyone around you and everyone you needed to impress in order to get the career or job you wanted looked down on you?

    Yes the people in these positions need to put in some hard work themselves, and help themselves. However there are deep social issues which have lead to this which are only compounded by those who think they are better than everyone else because they can afford to pay their council tax.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by SKoM, Cullompton

    Thursday, February 24 2011, 8:15PM

    “lmao face+palm
    Neils's comment is a small step from the eugenics that were seriously considered by some very senior statesmen who you would most definitely not refer to as Nazis

    Good idea, the ugly truth, it might just about stretch far enough for them to buy a packet of 10 fags each. The truth is that these fat cats' salaries are individually large, but in real terms account for very little.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters