BREAKING NEWS
 

'Shop rents are killing us'

Trusted article source icon
Monday, March 09, 2009
Profile image for This is Exeter

This is Exeter

High shop rents are killing of the chances of empty town centre shops being filled, it has been claimed.

Members of the Town Centres Company arranged a meeting with commercial agents last week, with the aim of finding ways to lower rents and fill vacant outlets.

  1. arthurchristian

    Arthur Christian

However, the meeting had to be cancelled because only two commercial agents said they would attend.

Arthur Christian, pictured, chairman of the of the chairman of Babbacombe and St Marychurch Chamber of Trade and a member of the Town Centres Company, was disappointed.

BUY ONE GET ONE FREE - Medium Cod, Chips & Mushy Peas at...

Kingfisher Fish & Chips

View details

Print voucher

Simply Purchase a Medium Cod, Chips and Mushy Peas and receive another portion for FREE.
Sustainable Cod, Fresh Cut Chips & Proper Mushy Peas.
Visit Our Website for more information and offers

Terms: Offer valid only with this Voucher, 1 voucher Per Customer. Not for use with any other offer, Not transferable to other menu items

Contact: 01752 421044

Valid until: Thursday, June 27 2013

He said: "We thought the commercial agents could help us engage with landlords, but they didn't seem too interested.

"I just don't understand it. Is it that they don't realise the severity of the situation?

"I think what we'll have to do is doorstep companies, meet them face-to-face and get them on board.

"I think the main reason why St Marychurch is doing well is because we're all here in the local economy, for the local economy.

"We're doing our best to make a living and employ a few people, instead of making money for our shareholders, the way national chains do."

Mayor Nick Bye said Torquay town centre prices could be 10 times the amount charged for somewhere like St Marychurch.

"The high rents are the reason why there are so many empty shops in the town centre," he said.

"I had a look in the window of a local commercial estate agents and it was fascinating.

"An empty shop in St Marychurch will rent for around £6,000 or £7,000 per annum. But in Union Street the rents are around £63,000 per annum.

"The town centre is busier than St Marychurch, but not 10 times busier."

Torquay town centre manager Lucy Ball claimed that landlords, who often have little connection with the Bay, set the premium rate rents when the economy was booming.

She said that the recession hasn't lowered the rents.

Ms Ball said: "If, for example, someone took out a 25-year lease seven or eight years ago and has gone out of business, the rent is still being paid on the lease but the premises is empty.

"As long as there is someone who is prepared to pay money for an empty building, the rent won't be lowered to encourage someone to occupy the shop.

"It doesn't pay the landlord to get someone in paying a lower rate."

But Mr Bye said landlords would have to fill up empty premises eventually.

"The situation will work itself out in the end because people want to come into the town centre," he added.

Paul Bettesworth, head of the real estate and industrial department at Bettesworths in Torquay, said: "A lot of landlords will still be receiving rent, but this is not the case everywhere.

"A lot of the prime shops were held on long-term leases. The rent review clauses only allow for rents to be increased. It is not the fault of the landlords. It is the way the system works."

Torbay Chamber of Trade chairman Christian Seiflow-Moran described the current situation as 'disgusting'.

"The rental value of one prime retail site in Torquay town centre was twice what I expected it to be.

"Often big corporations hold the leases, and it is more cost-effective for them to keep the premises empty.

"But landlords should be looking to fill the places up. It is disgusting. This is not just Torbay — it is across the country.

"The Government needs to look at its policy, and support tenants and landlords to fill up empty premises. This is a massive problem."

Last week the Local Government Authority said that England's high streets are in danger of becoming 'ghost towns' unless action is taken to fill empty shops.

The LGA is calling for new powers to allow town halls to temporarily use shops as sites for community projects.

The authority wants new powers to allow councils to take over shops once they have been vacant for three months, and a cut in the rate of VAT to five per cent on the refurbishment of empty shops.

Ms Ball thinks there is a need for a change in legislation to prevent shops lying empty, but she said the benefits depend on what empty units are used for.

She said: "Something is better than nothing, but we have to be careful that what goes into the units is beneficial."

Mr Seiflow-Moran added: "I don't see what local councils can do to fill up the properties because they are owned by private landlords.

"There will have to be a change in Government legislation to make this work."

PARKER'S PEN: Page 8

0
Tweet this article
Report

Comments

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by lifeblood, Paignton

    Tuesday, March 10 2009, 12:03AM

    “What no one is recognising is that the majority of agents are all based out of town. The landlords sit in their glass towers in london and have no idea what the situation is like in the 'provinces'. Now, with even the pound shops closing it would seem to make sense to reduce rents even if its just written into an agreement for the short term until the market picks up again. the other point is the owners of empty properties still have to pay out for them, rates become due after two months. Maybe a way forward is to offer to pay a rent equivalent to the landlords outlay for an empty premises. That way he might not be making anything but he will by having a full shop help to regenerate the town in the hope he may get a tenant who can afford to pay rent if its looking more like a place with a good economy. alternatively address the poverty here properly and who knows what social entrepreneurs would be on the up, its people with money to spend who make an economy. Equally the council should play their part by not giving over communtity buildings to commercial businesses, who can afford the rents elsewhere. Look at that new wine bar at the bottom of town, they are paying hardly any rent but have splashed out huge amounts on the redecoration. maybe they would have been better off paying the rent on the hoggs head putting that space back into use, spending less on redecoration and letting some kind of community enterprise use the old town hall.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Opressed commercial tenant, Torquay

    Monday, March 09 2009, 8:27PM

    “I am not suprised that the commercial agents were not interested, as it is those agents that set the rents on the commercial properties in Torquay and they act for the landlords, taking a percentage in fees of the final rent, therefore the higher the rent the higher their fees, no wonder they were not interested.

    Its about time something was done to stop them pushing the rents up on these properties, and allowing the traders to make a decent living, in a minute there will be landlords going bankrupt because they can't afford to pay the commercial mortgages on their premises as they don't have the tenents paying the extortionate rents.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Edwin Jefferson, Plymouth

    Monday, March 09 2009, 7:06PM

    “Tim the London Exile, we are not to blame. Madness to suggest we are.

    Baggins of Hove, yes, we have a mayor, but he doesn't care as he's bragging about parking meter takings of £15000 a week.

    Optimistic of torquay, the down turn is a recession. It won't be short lived, even if there is a "recovery", areas which won't be reported on will still be suffering. We are very likely going to be one of those areas, if you compare the appearance of our seafront, buildings and services, to those of other tourist resorts, we're a Blackpool without an amusement park, tower and trams.

    I have little hope left for Torbay, as we're worse off now than 10 years ago for jobs, services and general appearance of the area.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Gareth, Plainmoor

    Monday, March 09 2009, 5:05PM

    “I seem to have more money due to the recession, My food, fuel and even rent bills have dropped and my wage has stayed the same. Im know that not everyone is as fortunate in this respect but there is still money to be spent, unfortunately there are fewer places to spend it.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Optimistic, Torquay

    Monday, March 09 2009, 2:39PM

    “It's pretty straightforward - people are tightening their belts and doing a lot more window shopping and a lot less spending.

    Businesses can't afford the risk of renting an expensive town centre shop when shoppers are so reluctant to part with their cash, so no wonder so many places remain empty.

    If parking were free, it may bring more numbers into the towns, but if they don't have any money to spend in the first place, then I don't see how it can help.

    We just have to ride it out and hope this downturn is only short-lived.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Baggins, Hove E Sussex

    Monday, March 09 2009, 2:16PM

    “Treble rates on shops that remain empty due to non-downwardly-negeotiable rents.

    You've got a Mayor there haven't you? Can't he bite?”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Tim, London Exile

    Monday, March 09 2009, 1:27PM

    “It¿s ok talking about the greed of Landlords but we all have to remember that it was a boom in consumer spending that allowed landlords to charge high rents in the first place, so to a certain extent we are all to blame. Rents will fall but it will take a few months as current rents are a reflection of the capital value of the building, landlords will recognise the property is overvalued and rental expectation will be reduced. There are however, steps Torbay could take to help themselves in the meantime to encourage business in the town centres;

    a) Temporary removal of stringent planning regulations and fee holidays (within reason) to reduce the cost of establishing a business
    b) Temporary suspension or reduction of parking fees to increase footfall in the town centre
    c) Lobbying the government for a reduction in Business Rates to make Torbay an ¿Enterprise Zone¿ to encourage companies to invest.
    d) National press coverage highlighting the low cost base of the bay the beautiful environment and the quality of life to encourage relocation of companies with more sustainable jobs.

    In regard to point C Torbay would probably have a good chance due to the poor transport links to the rest of the country and the fact that the average wage is less than the national average.

    Mind you we could always take the view of the current administration, sit on our hands and say there is nothing we can do!”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by john, stanley

    Monday, March 09 2009, 1:16PM

    “am i coming on holiday this year to torquay. a big no... why PARKING CHARGES. traffic wardens,,...has the people running the town gone mad????????jf”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by john farmer, stanley

    Monday, March 09 2009, 1:12PM

    “after having shops intorquay for 18 years i am amazed the greedy landlords have`nt reduced the rents, one only has to look at the centre of town and torquay market to see a ghost town.i pity the poor retailers who never had the sense to see the downtown, and the greedy banks high charges,they are out to destroy one third of all retailers inthe bay. the blame of course for all this problems is greedy banks and so called professionals that has got the area in a mess, one only has to go back years to see the bay starved of investment, one has to look at sedgefield, beautiful area, mr blairs ex constinuancy to see where all the money has gone jf”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Simon Pieman, Paignton

    Monday, March 09 2009, 12:05PM

    “I have been looking at commercial properties in Torbay for that last few years as I would like to open a new business, but have found that the rental costs and lease terms just make it way too a big a risk. Even now landlords seem to have their heads stuck in the sand and are not being flexible which is why many retailers are getting out. There will be a backlash and I predict that some commercial properties will be going for a song in about 9 months times but by then who would want to open a business in ghost town?”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Be the first to comment

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article