Wind farms are risk to national treasure
IN the WMN (April 6) Energy Secretary Ed Miliband warns that communities in the Westcountry have "no option" but to support a "massive expansion" of wind farms.
Does he think we are the only ones who care about what happens to the countryside? Many of the people who live in cities but come down here on holiday will be shocked and angry too when they find that the places they love have been turned into, or are surrounded by, wind power stations.
-

The view from the edge of Braunton Burrows, taken after turning inland on the coast footpath, past Crow Point
The sand dunes of Braunton Burrows are one such place: a national treasure and internationally famous. The picture with this letter is the view from the edge of the Burrows, taken after turning inland on the coast footpath, past Crow Point. Soon this facing line of hills will be sprouting with the giant (361ft) turbines of the Fullabrook Down wind farm.
As can be seen on the website I run – www.artistsagainstwind farms.com – even bigger (400ft high) turbines could look down on to the Burrows as well, from the opposite side of the Taw Estuary at Yelland.
With more turbines threatened across Bideford Bay at Parkham, the character of the Burrows could be altered drastically – dominated from most sides by industrial turbines. And the "massive expansion" has not even started yet.
As my father, James Lovelock, the environmental scientist, said in the WMN on April 3, wind farms are "no answer to global warming".
The more we rely on wind power, the more likely it is that the lights will go off – just when we need them most, in the middle of cold midwinter anticyclones.
And, because wind power needs conventional power stations as back-up, it does little to reduce CO2 emissions.
Ed Miliband has also said that protests against wind farms should be "socially unacceptable". Energy security and climate change are such serious issues that he should instead welcome all serious scrutiny of government policies on these matters.
Christine Lovelock
Barnstaple
Tories snub Europe
THE current state of David Cameron's Conservative Party links with our European partners illustrates how the Tory Party is much nearer the ideology of UKIP rather than in the centre of British politics.
Patrick Nicholls attempts to make light of his party's policies of turning its back on Europe and Britain's most important trading and economic partners.
At a time of global economic and political crisis, Britain needs to work closer with Europe rather than follow deputy Tory leader William Hague's philosophy of moving in with hard right political parties on the fringe of Europe rather than in the centre, thereby undermining Tory values ("UKIP is back from brink", Patrick Nicholls, WMN April 2).
It will be interesting to see if shadow Business Secretary Kenneth Clarke and others can keep quiet while the Tory Party becomes more anti-European than any other Conservative shadow administration from the past.
Mr Nicholls also makes an important claim in stating that "policy is not for sale in the Conservative Party, no matter how large your wallet".
Does this extend to millionaires like Lord Ashcroft, who fund marginal parliamentary seats in a similar way to the old rotten borough scandals of yesteryear?
Mr Cameron is finding it difficult to hold the anti-European and pro-European factions in the Conservative Party together, but to allow the rabid anti-European clique to dominate policy on Europe is bad for the Conservatives and bad for Britain.
Dr David Pedrick-Friend
Labour Prospective Candidate for Torbay Paignton
Dismiss Draper
I NOTE that Damian McBride is "shocked and appalled at the way the e-mails had been leaked". Had they not been dreamed up and sent, there would have been nothing to leak. If this man has so little real work to do that he can compile such comment, why was he employed by the Prime Minister?
Further, what is being done over Derek Draper? He also works for the Labour Party and thought the "comments" were "absolutely, totally brilliant, Damian. I'll think about timing and sort out the technology this week so we can go as soon as possible".
Surely with a man like that, who runs the Labour List website, we are entitled to ask what real work he does, and his dismissal is surely a prerequisite to any apology coming from Mr Brown – but don't hold your breath.
Finally, when Alastair Campbell adds his criticism, we know without doubt that such people – who are unelected – should be prosecuted for this terrible action.
Mike Bennett
Barnstaple
Stand up to Miliband
I AM really worried that, unless Cornwall Council and South West MPs stand up to the Government, we will see the unique Cornish landscape trashed by more wind farms.
It is time the powers that be of Cornwall really studied renewable energy and what will and will not work. If they choose to believe Ed Miliband when he infers that 95 per cent of the region support wind power, Cornwall is doomed – but if they have any credibility they will face down Mr Miliband and the poor solution of wind power.
If we have wind power, we will have blackouts, not a secure supply, and we will also have a poor tourist industry.
If you look at the annual power from wind farms across the UK you will see that Cornwall's wind farms perform perhaps 2 per cent better than the few in Oxfordshire, and in some cases worse – so to say the South West has exceptional wind resources is not entirely true.
Perhaps Mr Milliband should face down the South East and build a Thames barrage like the proposed Severn barrage.
C Wright
Camelford
Misguided missile
CONSIDERING the direction and payload uncertainty of the North Korean missile, it prompts the question: Why didn't the US shoot it down?
Barrie Yelland
Helston











4 Comments
by Theo H, Lifton
Thursday, April 16 2009, 4:45PM
“I'm all for a nuke, right here in Lifton. But if there is not enough cooling water in nearby Roadford Lake resevoir, then anywhere on the mile upon mile of Cornish coast.
But wait until you hear the screams of the Nimbys about that one.
There was a recent proposal to just _look_ for a radioactive waste disposal site in Cornawall, and the Nimbys screamed.
What people want in the Westcountry is (electrical) power without responsibility.
Theo H”
by Bob Ashton, Bratton Fleming
Thursday, April 16 2009, 4:33PM
“Short of any rational argument to defend the bunch of incompetent Muppets currently in office, D P-F stirs the smelly stuff again.
There must be a General Election in the offing.”
by Will, Crediton
Thursday, April 16 2009, 1:31PM
“Beauty is in the eye of the beholder - in some people's eyes our wind farms ARE a national treasure!”
by FWK, Crediton
Thursday, April 16 2009, 12:48PM
“Christine Lovelock - of course wind farms are not THE answer to global warming, there is no one answer, but it is not true to say they are "no answer". We need a variety of sustainable methods of generating electricity from natural resources and it makes sense to use as many as possible - including wind power. We should also be using much more solar power - every new housing development could be a mini power station, as could millions of existing homes, given sufficient grant aid and political will. We should be making far more use of tidal and wave power and hydroelectric to name a few. We have left all this so late now that we are probably going to have to do as James Lovelock has suggested - increase our reliance on nuclear power, at least as a stopgap.
No, wind farms are not the only fruit, but they are part of the fruit salad that we should be putting together.
As for aesthetics, which would you rather see on the hillside, a wind farm or a coal-fired power station (or even a nuclear power station)?”