One of worst noise nuisance cases investigated in Plymouth

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, February 07, 2012
Profile image for Plymouth Herald

Plymouth Herald

A NEIGHBOUR was plagued by loud dance music from a flat two floors away in one of the worst noise nuisance cases investigated by a council officer, a court heard.

Plymouth magistrates found Patrick McShane, aged 28, guilty in his absence of four breaches of an order to turn down the bass-heavy music played at his Devonport home.

McShane was told to appear at court for failing to comply with an abatement notice on four days in May last year. But he did not attend.

The court was told on one occasion the woman two floors below his flat in Granby Street was forced to sleep at a friend's house because of the loud music.

He already has one conviction for failing to comply with the same abatement notice, issued back in April 2010.

Sharon Day, prosecuting for Plymouth City Council, said the neighbour who lived on the ground floor first complained about the loud music coming from the plasterer's flat in January 2010.

She added the complaints continued into March and April, when monitoring equipment was installed in the woman's flat.

Mrs Day said: "Given that the complainant was two floors below the source of the music, the environmental health officer found it was one of the worst cases she had dealt with.

"It was impossible to have a conversation, read a book or watch television."

The court heard that McShane was issued with an abatement notice and later given a conditional discharge for breaching it.

Mrs Day said the neighbour called officers back to the flat in May of last year.

She added that the council recorded what was regarded as loud thumping trance or drum and bass music at different times on four days.

Mrs Day said that on one night the woman left the flat to stay at a friend's house because her granddaughter could not sleep.

The court heard that McShane has previous convictions for assault, driving while disqualified and fraud.

The council case was delayed while he served a prison sentence.

Magistrates adjourned the case until February 20, when McShane will be asked to attend.

9
Tweet this article
Report

9 Comments

  • Profile image for hay_sammy

    by hay_sammy

    Tuesday, February 07 2012, 10:07PM

    “just cut off his electric! - so what if he cant cook or heat up the flat, at least the little ***** would be quiet.”

  • Profile image for renegade2009

    by renegade2009

    Tuesday, February 07 2012, 6:48PM

    “bang him up and let him think of whats hes done then when out dont give him a newe place”

  • Profile image for marc1964

    by marc1964

    Tuesday, February 07 2012, 6:32PM

    “if he wants to make noise get a tent and live with the occupy wierdos. they will love the attention”

  • Profile image for MickBarb

    by MickBarb

    Tuesday, February 07 2012, 6:20PM

    “If the police and councils can't sort these things out, I foresee a rise in vigilantism as fed-up citizens tackle the offenders themselves in one way or another..”

  • Profile image for Potbelly1

    by Potbelly1

    Tuesday, February 07 2012, 6:07PM

    “What about the people who lived next door to this knob!... obviously too scared to complain about someone who already has convictions for assault! why does it have to take a Grandmother who lives 2 floors below to sort him out!I hope he gets banged up once again and again and again and again ....”

  • Profile image for o0Dj0o

    by o0Dj0o

    Tuesday, February 07 2012, 12:34PM

    “simple solution, wait until there out contact there letting agent as you have concerns for there welfare, the landlord will open the property in conjunction with attending officers at that point show the landlord/agent the council and police notice..................Tenant is then served with a eviction notice depending on the seriousness of the order.


    this is exactly what i did when in a similar position and have remained richard curanim free for the last couple of years.”

  • Profile image for trudie2010

    by trudie2010

    Tuesday, February 07 2012, 10:19AM

    “Didn't take the council long to rectify the problem. lol”

  • Profile image for Snapdragons

    by Snapdragons

    Tuesday, February 07 2012, 9:48AM

    “Total disrespect for the law, total disrespect for the law abiding people of Plymouth.”

  • Profile image for blond13

    by blond13

    Tuesday, February 07 2012, 7:49AM

    “Try having a family of 10 living next door to you!”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters